Faced with underperforming boutiques, Elf made the strategic choice to shut them down. They immediately reinvested the $16 million in operational savings into their core growth channels—digital marketing and national retail partnerships—which accelerated overall business momentum.

Related Insights

During its COVID-era pivot, Lifetime replaced its entire sales team with a "concierge" service focused on member experience and ceased all traditional advertising. This counter-intuitive strategy, focused purely on product quality and customer help, led to a doubling of revenue in three years and waitlists at many locations.

T3's journey with Sephora shows that retail relationships are dynamic. After a successful launch, they were removed from brick-and-mortar stores for nearly a decade, surviving on online sales. They later returned to shelves by introducing new, innovative products. This illustrates that losing shelf space isn't final and can be regained with fresh offerings.

Contrary to common belief for online-native brands, Peak Design's own retail stores have the highest contribution margin. This is because shipping products in bulk freight to stores is cheaper than covering the high last-mile delivery costs for individual e-commerce orders, which often qualify for free shipping.

The company never proactively pitched major retailers. Instead, they focused on creating a powerful digital presence and a superior product. This strategy made the brand so desirable that major players like Sephora initiated the partnership, flipping the traditional wholesale sales dynamic.

Sephora combats intense competition by applying a "game of inches" philosophy to its physical retail space. Every section, from teen-focused fragrance displays to strategically placed checkout-line minis, is optimized to sell. This meticulous space utilization creates a highly profitable, frictionless customer experience without any "wasted" space.

Upon joining, a new marketing leader at Common Room cut the marketing budget in half by eliminating low-impact activities like a generic content agency and events. This freed up resources to double down on promising areas, resulting in a 30-50% pipeline increase the following quarter, proving that strategic cuts can fuel growth.

Instead of seeking synergies by integrating acquired companies like Hailey Bieber's Rhode, Elf Beauty keeps the founder and their team in place. The goal is to provide resources like sales support and R&D to help the founder's original vision scale faster, avoiding common M&A pitfalls.

Coterie treats its physical retail presence not just as a sales channel, but as a marketing tool. A well-placed product block acts like a billboard, driving discovery and funneling 10-12% of new customers back to their primary D2C subscription business.

Elf's CEO asserts the company is in the "entertainment industry," not beauty. This mindset shifts their marketing focus from selling products to delighting their community. It justifies tactics like a Twitch channel or airdropping care packages, which build brand love over direct ROI.

Elf maintains low prices by embedding its own quality control and lean manufacturing teams within partner supplier facilities. This hybrid model gives them a high degree of control over cost and speed, allowing them to sell products like a $3 lipstick profitably, even amidst inflation and tariffs.