Historian Sven Beckert frames capitalism as a constantly shape-shifting system. Its dramatic evolution over 1,000 years—from colonial models to Keynesianism—suggests the current neoliberal order is not a permanent state but will likely be replaced by a substantially different version.
Related Insights
The post-1980s neoliberal consensus of small government and free trade is being replaced by a mercantilist approach. Governments, particularly the U.S., now actively intervene to protect domestic industries and secure geopolitical strength, treating trade as a zero-sum game. This represents a fundamental economic shift for investors.
The potential for an AI-driven, post-capitalist world of abundance is real. However, the path there will likely be as destructive as a world war, as the rapid upending of the economic order will throw society into chaos before stability is achieved.
To counter the economic threat from China's state-directed capitalism, the U.S. is ironically being forced to adopt similar strategies. This involves greater government intervention in capital allocation and industrial policy, representing a convergence of economic models rather than a clear victory for free-market capitalism.
The current system is locked in because policymakers fear the consequences of letting asset prices fall. A genuine shift will only occur when a political figure gains power with a mandate to help the middle class, even if it means 'suffering the consequences' of a market crash.
The advent of super-intelligent AI challenges the core tenets of free-market capitalism. When human labor competes against entities that are exponentially more capable, the 'creative destruction' model could lead to mass unemployment and social instability, forcing a move away from pure capitalism.
Historian Sven Beckert argues that capitalism did not originate in Europe and spread outward. Its very existence from the start depended on planetary connections and co-production between many cultures, making it inherently global from its inception, not a Western invention.
Dalio argues that the convergence of five historical forces—debt cycles, internal conflict (wealth gaps), shifting world order, acts of nature, and technology—drives major societal changes. Understanding these interconnected cycles provides a clearer long-term perspective than focusing on daily news.
The system often blamed as capitalism is distorted. True capitalism requires the risk of failure as a clearing mechanism. Today's system is closer to cronyism, where government interventions like bailouts and regulatory capture protect established players from failure.
During its boom, Japan's industrial policy and close bank-firm relationships were admired as strengths. After the bubble burst, these same traits were immediately relabeled as crony capitalism and systemic flaws, showing how quickly dominant narratives about national economic models can invert.
Modern capitalism profitably hacks primitive human drives (e.g., junk food, social media), redirecting them away from natural behaviors like reproduction. This cultural trajectory could be an evolutionary dead-end, where the system selects against its own continuation by fostering sterility, paving the way for its replacement by a different culture.
