High-profile CEOs from large corporations frequently struggle as LBO operating partners. They are accustomed to vast resources and being the sole boss, a mentality that clashes with the mentorship and resource-constrained environment of smaller portfolio companies.
While the process of acquiring businesses is exciting, managing a large portfolio of acquired companies shifts the CEO's job dramatically. The role becomes less about the 'chase' of deals and growth, and more about managing personnel issues, retaining key talent from acquired firms, and solving interpersonal conflicts—a draining reality of scale.
PE sponsors can accelerate value creation by telling new CEOs that some new executive hires are expected to fail. This pre-approval removes the CEO's fear of appearing to have failed themselves, encouraging them to make necessary talent changes faster and more decisively.
To maximize value creation, young private equity firm Teopo Capital made a strategic decision to hire a full-time operating partner dedicated to portfolio companies before building out a fundraising team. This signals a deep commitment to hands-on operational improvement as their core strategy.
Many VC firms hire former operators for their expertise, but success isn't guaranteed. The best operator-VCs avoid the urge to "backseat drive" the companies they fund. Instead, they leverage their experience with extraordinary humility, acting as a supportive advisor rather than a replacement CEO.
Founders often chase executives from successful scaled companies. However, these execs can fail because their experience makes them overly critical and resistant to the painful, hands-on work required at an early stage. The right hire is often someone a few layers down from the star executive.
Corporate leaders are incentivized and wired to pursue growth through acquisition, constantly getting bigger. However, they consistently fail at the strategically crucial, but less glamorous, task of divesting assets at the right time, often holding on until value has significantly eroded.
Unlike operating companies that seek consistency, VC firms hunt for outliers. This requires a 'stewardship' model that empowers outlier talent with autonomy. A traditional, top-down CEO model that enforces uniformity would stifle the very contrarian thinking necessary for venture success. The job is to enable, not manage.
The transition from a C-suite operator managing thousands to an investor is jarring. New VCs must adapt from leading large teams to being individual contributors who write their own memos and do their own sourcing. This "scaling down" ability, not just prior success, predicts their success as an investor.
Operating partners add maximum value when involved pre-acquisition. They should help shape the value creation plan and deal thesis from the start, rather than being brought in post-close simply to execute a plan others have created.
When a private equity investment thesis is primarily built around a single person (e.g., a star CEO), it's a sign of weak conviction in the underlying business. If that person fails or leaves, the entire rationale for the investment collapses, revealing a lack of fundamental belief in the company's industry or competitive position.