Instead of shutting down disruptive individuals, musician Jacob Collier disarms them by 'radically incorporating' their outburst. By making the entire group repeat the heckler's idea, he validates them, dissolves their disruptive power, and brings them back into the collective.
To get a group to accept unconventional ideas, first conform to its established values to build trust. This earns you "idiosyncrasy credits," which you can later "spend" on deviating from the norm without being rejected. This 'conform, then innovate' strategy was used by The Beatles to gain mainstream acceptance before experimenting.
When former neo-Nazi Jeff Scoop tried to escalate a conversation by pounding his fist, musician Daryl Davis's calm, non-reactive response broke the script. This unexpected de-escalation made Jeff curious and receptive, rather than more defensive.
Jacob Collier explains that beautiful music relies on controlling dissonance (tension), not just playing pleasant notes (consonance). This applies to teams: leaning into creative tension and resolving it leads to a more meaningful outcome than avoiding disagreement altogether.
In disagreements, the objective isn't to prove the other person wrong or "win" the argument. The true goal is to achieve mutual understanding. This fundamental shift in perspective transforms a confrontational dynamic into a collaborative one, making difficult conversations more productive.
Jacob Collier builds trust by arranging well-known songs. This allows him to play with the audience's existing expectations, demonstrating creativity within a familiar framework. This strategy establishes credibility before asking an audience to engage with entirely new material.
When a senior stakeholder proposes a potentially disruptive idea, direct resistance ('pushing') is counterproductive and strengthens their resolve. Instead, 'pull' them into a collaborative exploration. Acknowledge the idea, discuss the underlying problem it solves, and then gently steer the conversation back to how it aligns with the agreed-upon North Star, defusing tension.
To encourage participation from everyone, leaders should focus on the 'why' behind an idea (intention) and ask curious questions rather than judging the final output. This levels the playing field by rewarding effort and thoughtfulness over innate talent, making it safe for people to share imperfect ideas.
The "looping" technique—repeating what you heard and asking "Did I get that right?"—is effective in conflicts even if your interpretation is incorrect. The act of trying to understand and giving them power to correct you demonstrates genuine intent, making the other person feel heard and reducing defensiveness.
Collier's audience choirs are a leadership model inspired by his conductor mother. The core principle is not musical skill, but 'mass permissioning'—creating a safe environment where a large group feels empowered to participate, fostering inclusivity and shared joy.
Instead of personally challenging a guest, read a critical quote about them from another source. This reframes you as a neutral moderator giving them a chance to respond, rather than an attacker. The guest has likely already prepared an answer for known criticisms.