In 2004, Apple considered a credit card whose points could only buy iTunes songs. This was economically brilliant for Apple due to high margins on digital music. However, the rise of streaming services like Spotify would have quickly rendered this reward system obsolete, highlighting the risk of tying loyalty programs to a single, disruptable product category.
Related Insights
Unlike typical co-branded credit card portfolios that sell for a premium, Goldman Sachs offloaded the Apple Card's debt to JPMorgan at a significant loss. This underscores the program's unprofitability, driven by high defaults and operational costs, despite the prestigious Apple brand.
Brands often misinterpret repeat purchases driven by discounts or points as genuine loyalty. True loyalty is an emotional connection, not a transactional one. This "entrapment" model fails to build lasting customer relationships or brand affinity.
Steve Jobs fostered an inclusive premium brand accessible to anyone with money. Applying this to the Apple Card meant low credit score requirements, which conflicted with the financial necessity of risk-based rejection in lending. This philosophical mismatch contributed significantly to Goldman Sachs's portfolio losses and the partnership's failure.
For high-end brands hesitant to offer discounts, Apple's model is ideal. They sell products at full price but include a substantial gift card for future purchases. This drives sales and encourages repeat business without ever putting the core product "on sale," thus preserving brand prestige.
Steve Jobs' vision of Apple as an inclusive brand conflicted with the necessary exclusivity of credit risk assessment. This led to lower underwriting standards (credit scores around 600) for the Apple Card, contributing to its poor performance and eventual sale by Goldman Sachs at a discount.
An early version of the Apple Card proposed "iPoints" redeemable exclusively for 99¢ songs on iTunes. While economically brilliant for Apple (capturing a 30% margin on redemptions), this closed ecosystem was less appealing than cash back or travel and would have become obsolete with the rise of streaming music.
TiVo focused its resources on legally defending its DVR patent, its "moat." This strategic fixation caused it to completely miss the rise of streaming, a disruption that made its core technology irrelevant. Protecting an advantage can create a dangerous blind spot to bigger, external threats.
Thompson critiques Apple's lucrative services strategy as a shift from creating the best products to "harvesting the profits from other companies' innovations." The argument is that this rent-seeking behavior is corrosive to the company's core DNA of product excellence and innovation.
Don't just sell a product; become an indispensable part of your customer's workflow. By offering integrated products and services, you create a value ecosystem that locks out competitors and makes leaving an impractical and undesirable option.
The system of charging retailers an interchange fee (around 1.8%) that is then passed to consumers as rewards (around 1.57%) creates a strong network effect. Consumers are incentivized to use rewards cards, and retailers cannot easily offer discounts for other payment methods, locking both parties into the ecosystem.
