To appeal to the "layperson" rather than tech early adopters, Comet's designers made the core browser experience familiar, like Google Chrome. This reduces cognitive load, allowing users to focus their limited learning bandwidth on the novel AI features, even if it disappoints power users expecting a radical redesign.
Related Insights
Don't feel pressured to label every AI-powered enhancement as an "AI feature." For example, using AI to generate CSS for a new dark mode is simply a better way to build. The focus should be on the user benefit (dark mode), not the underlying technology, making AI an invisible, powerful tool.
Instead of trying to convert skeptics, AMP focuses exclusively on users already at the frontier of AI adoption. They believe that building for someone who doesn't know how to prompt well forces them to build simplistic features and fall behind the pace of innovation.
Existing AI tools are good at either "asking" for information (e.g., search) or "doing" a task. AI-first browsers like Comet struggle because browsing requires seamlessly blending both intents, a difficult product challenge that has not yet been effectively solved, hindering their adoption.
The Browser Company's vision shifted from optimizing tab management to seeing the browser as the ideal "personal intelligence layer." The browser itself is just the enabling technology; the real value comes from using its unique access to all user context (apps, queries, history) to power a miraculous AI assistant.
The best agentic UX isn't a generic chat overlay. Instead, identify where users struggle with complex inputs like formulas or code. Replace these friction points with a native, natural language interface that directly integrates the AI into the core product workflow, making it feel seamless and powerful.
Open-ended prompts overwhelm new users who don't know what's possible. A better approach is to productize AI into specific features. Use familiar UI like sliders and dropdowns to gather user intent, which then constructs a complex prompt behind the scenes, making powerful AI accessible without requiring prompt engineering skills.
The Browser Company found that Arc, while loved by tech enthusiasts for its many new features, created a "novelty tax." This cognitive overhead for learning a new interface made mass-market users hesitant to switch, a key lesson that informed the simplicity of their next product, Dia.
The most effective application of AI isn't a visible chatbot feature. It's an invisible layer that intelligently removes friction from existing user workflows. Instead of creating new work for users (like prompt engineering), AI should simplify experiences, like automatically surfacing a 'pay bill' link without the user ever consciously 'using AI.'
The most effective AI user experiences are skeuomorphic, emulating real-world human interactions. Design an AI onboarding process like you would hire a personal assistant: start with small tasks, verify their work to build trust, and then grant more autonomy and context over time.
When competing with AI giants, The Browser Company's strategy isn't a traditional moat like data or distribution. It's rooted in their unique "sensibility" and "vibes." This suggests that as AI capabilities commoditize, a product's distinct point of view, taste, and character become key differentiators.