Contrary to conventional wisdom, a stronger renminbi would exacerbate China's deflationary pressures. This would harm corporate revenues, leading to wage cuts and negatively impacting consumer spending. Therefore, currency appreciation would make the desired economic rebalancing towards consumption more difficult.

Related Insights

A key tension exists for Asian FX. China's central bank is keeping the Yuan stable, providing an anchor for the region. Simultaneously, weak Chinese stocks are driving negative risk sentiment. This forces regional currencies into a difficult choice of which signal to follow, leading to uncertainty.

Despite accumulating massive deposits (100 trillion RMB), Chinese households are reluctant to spend. This is driven by the need to "self-insure" due to a limited social safety net and concerns over wealth destruction from the property downturn. Boosting consumption requires structural policy changes, not just stimulus.

Beijing's political commitment to annual growth targets prevents it from allowing the economy to slow down and rebalance. Instead of fostering sustainable consumption, it must constantly stimulate investment and exports, perpetuating the very imbalances that threaten long-term stability.

China reports 5% real GDP growth while experiencing persistent deflation. This is historically unprecedented for an investment-led economy, with the only possible parallel being the 19th-century U.S. The inconsistency suggests official growth numbers are not credible.

China's policy to combat deflation focuses on cutting excess industrial capacity. However, this is deemed insufficient because the root cause is weak aggregate demand. A sustainable solution requires boosting consumption through social welfare, an approach policymakers seem hesitant to implement on a large scale.

China’s economic strategy prioritizes technology and manufacturing competitiveness, assuming this will create a virtuous cycle of profits, jobs, and consumption. The key risk is that automated, high-tech manufacturing may not generate enough jobs to significantly boost household income, causing consumer spending to lag behind industrial growth.

In response to deflation and eroding profits from hyper-competition, the Chinese government's "anti-evolution" policy is a deliberate strategy to force consolidation, reduce overcapacity, and restore pricing power, thereby boosting corporate return on equity.

Despite rhetoric about shifting to a consumption-led economy, China's rigid annual GDP growth targets make this impossible. This political necessity forces a constant return to state-driven fixed asset investment to hit the numbers. The result is a "cha-cha" of economic policy—one step toward rebalancing, two steps back toward the old model—making any true shift short-lived.

China deliberately maintains an undervalued renminbi to make its exports cheaper globally. This strategy props up its manufacturing-led growth model, even though it hinders economic rebalancing and reduces the purchasing power of its own citizens.

The Chinese Yuan's (CNY) recent strength, particularly against the Euro, is not just a market phenomenon. It reflects a deliberate PBOC policy to manage the EuroCNH cross to placate European concerns over China's massive trade surplus, making EuroCNH a key political and policy indicator.