Home Depot succeeded by "counter-positioning" against incumbents like Sears. Their high-volume, low-price model was so different that if Sears tried to adopt it, they would have damaged their existing high-margin business. This strategic dilemma paralyzed competitors, allowing Home Depot to capture the market.
Instead of copying what top competitors do well, analyze what they do poorly or neglect. Excelling in those specific areas creates a powerful differentiator. This is how Eleven Madison Park focused on rivals' bad coffee service to become the world's #1 restaurant.
Established industries often operate like cartels with unwritten rules, such as avoiding aggressive marketing. New entrants gain a significant edge by deliberately violating these norms, forcing incumbents to react to a game they don't want to play. This creates differentiation beyond the core product or service.
Prepared realized it couldn't win against GovTech incumbents on their terms of sales relationships and lobbying. Their strategy was to fundamentally shift the competition. By offering a free, easy-to-use product, they forced the purchasing decision to be about technology quality, an arena where they could excel.
Sears' decline was epitomized by a CEO who felt like a "stranger" in his own stores and pursued abstract corporate strategies. In contrast, Home Depot mandated that every executive spend time on the floor, ensuring that strategic decisions were grounded in the reality of the customer experience.
Startups often fail by making a slightly better version of an incumbent's product. This is a losing strategy because the incumbent can easily adapt. The key is to build something so fundamentally different in structure that competitors have a very hard time copying it, ensuring a durable advantage.
The fundamental goal is to become a "better competitive alternative" for a specific customer—being so superior that they bypass competitors to choose you. Achieving this state is the business equivalent of the house advantage in a casino (“the house vig”) and the only reliable way to build a lasting enterprise.
Koenigsegg viewed his lack of automotive heritage not as a weakness but as his greatest competitive advantage. Without legacy constraints, he could start from a "blank sheet of paper," enabling radical innovation and differentiation that incumbents, tied to their history and processes, could not easily replicate.
When competitors like Compaq dismissed Dell as a "mail order company" or "garage operation," Dell viewed it as a powerful advantage. Their underestimation meant they didn't see him coming and failed to properly analyze his disruptive business model, giving him cover to grow.
When a Home Depot store became too successful and couldn't handle more volume, the company's solution was to open another one nearby. This self-cannibalization strategy allowed them to capture total market share, ensuring customers bought from a Home Depot, even if it meant stealing from an existing location.
Home Depot became the default shopping destination for so many customers that manufacturers faced a choice: sell through Home Depot or lose access to consumers who wouldn't seek them elsewhere. This created a powerful network effect where scale attracted key suppliers, which reinforced customer loyalty and solidified their market dominance.