Sears' decline was epitomized by a CEO who felt like a "stranger" in his own stores and pursued abstract corporate strategies. In contrast, Home Depot mandated that every executive spend time on the floor, ensuring that strategic decisions were grounded in the reality of the customer experience.
Related Insights
A founder's real boss is their customer base. While keeping a board happy is important, some CEOs become so consumed with managing up that they lose sight of the product and customer needs, ultimately driving the company off a cliff despite running perfect board meetings.
To stay connected to frontline operations and customer sentiment, former EasyJet CEO Caroline McCall made it a ritual to help cabin crew collect trash on every flight. This simple, repeated act provided invaluable, unfiltered feedback from both employees and passengers that she couldn't get in the office.
A new CEO’s first few months are best spent gathering unfiltered information directly from employees and customers across the business. Avoid the trap of sitting in an office listening to prepared presentations. Instead, actively listen in the field, then act decisively based on those firsthand insights.
Home Depot succeeded by "counter-positioning" against incumbents like Sears. Their high-volume, low-price model was so different that if Sears tried to adopt it, they would have damaged their existing high-margin business. This strategic dilemma paralyzed competitors, allowing Home Depot to capture the market.
The most critical insights for Chili's revival came not from consumers, but from its 70,000 employees. Their feedback on operational friction and guest interactions directly fueled simplification, menu changes, and investments that improved the customer experience.
Target's '10-4' customer service rule originated at Walmart, which went beyond just stating the rule. Walmart installed a 10-foot-long sticker on the floor as a physical measuring tool for employees. This demonstrates a powerful management principle: turning abstract cultural values into concrete, tangible, and measurable actions in the physical workspace.
A sales leader's value isn't in managing from headquarters. It's in being on the front lines, personally engaging in the most challenging deals to figure out the winning sales motion. Only after living in the field and closing landmark deals can they effectively build a playbook and teach the team.
Home Depot's decentralized model gives regional presidents significant autonomy but with clear, unspoken boundaries—the "invisible fence." This fosters local ownership and agility while ensuring alignment with core company principles. Crossing the line results in a "zap," maintaining strategic cohesion without micromanagement.
After the problematic Bowwater acquisition, Home Depot's founders realized their growth ambitions were outpacing operational capacity. In an act of self-regulation, they asked their board to pass a resolution capping annual growth at 25%, using their governance structure to enforce discipline and prevent future mistakes.
Hamdi Ulukaya attributes Chobani's success in scaling without sacrificing product quality to his extreme operational commitment. For years, he rarely left the factory floor, ensuring standards were met firsthand. This underscores the value of deep, physical immersion for leaders in manufacturing and operations.
