The fitness industry's fearmongering about cortisol is misleading. The acute cortisol increase during exercise is a normal, necessary response for regulating blood pressure and glucose. It does not contribute to the fat storage seen in chronic conditions like Cushing's syndrome.
Related Insights
Shifting to a low-carbohydrate diet increases baseline cortisol because the body needs to mobilize energy stores more actively. This can lead to feelings of being "wired but tired" and can disrupt sleep, especially during the adaptation period.
For Type-A personalities and entrepreneurs already operating in a high-stress state, intense exercise can be counterproductive. It spikes cortisol levels, exacerbating stress on the nervous system. Gentle movement like walking is often more effective for genuine regulation and recovery.
The evolutionary "fight or flight" response floods the body with hormones like cortisol to handle immediate threats. This life-saving mechanism comes at a cost: it diverts resources away from non-essential functions like digestion. Chronic stress therefore leads to a chronically sacrificed and weakened gut.
Happiness (positive affect) and unhappiness (negative affect) are processed in different parts of the brain; they are not opposites on a single scale. Vigorous exercise is a powerful tool for managing and lowering negative affect, such as anxiety and cortisol, but it doesn't necessarily boost positive affect.
When addressing hormone imbalances, start at the base of the "hormone pyramid." Optimizing foundational hormones like cortisol (stress) and insulin (blood sugar) is essential, as they directly impact thyroid function and sex hormones like estrogen and testosterone.
Contrary to popular internet wisdom, data shows that cold plunges do not increase cortisol. Instead, they decrease cortisol while boosting adrenaline, dopamine, and norepinephrine, making you alert and focused without the negative stress hormone response.
Cortisol isn't just a negative stress hormone. The "cortisol awakening response" is a natural, healthy spike that provides the energy and alertness needed to start your day. Optimizing this spike is crucial for setting your entire daily rhythm.
Melissa Wood Tepperberg replaced other addictions with an obsessive, two-hour-a-day workout regimen. This high-stress approach, pumping her body with cortisol, was counterproductive, leading to weight gain and feeling worse. This shows how seemingly healthy habits can become another form of self-punishment.
The temporary increase in hormones like testosterone and growth hormone after a workout is not the primary driver of long-term muscle growth. Structuring workouts specifically to maximize this acute response is ineffective and not predictive of long-term adaptation.
Failing to achieve a high cortisol peak in the morning results in a "flattened" cortisol curve. This makes your system over-reactive to stress later in the day, leading to larger, more lasting cortisol spikes that disrupt sleep and cause anxiety.