Brands like Five Guys succeed by focusing on one core offering. Psychological studies show that adding extra, less significant benefits can reduce a customer's belief in the primary, most important benefit. This is known as the "goal dilution effect."
Overdelivering by packing too much into a tiny offer makes it vague and less appealing. A hyper-specific offer that solves a customer's immediate, perceived want (like an "abs workout") will outperform a broad offer that tries to address their actual, complex needs (like overall fitness).
Companies try to communicate too many benefits at once (security, ease of use, efficiency), creating a "mishmash buffet" that prospects can't digest. To provide focus and avoid messaging by committee, companies need a single, clear "flagship message" that guides all communication.
Resist the common marketing urge to stack features or "reasons to believe." Like the fast-growing Five Guys burger chain, focusing on a single, excellent offering can create a stronger brand and attract more customers than trying to appeal to everyone with a wide-ranging menu of products.
The 'pratfall effect' suggests that admitting a weakness can increase appeal. For brands, this works best when the admitted flaw cleverly emphasizes a core strength. For example, Buckley's cough syrup's 'It tastes awful. And it works' campaign uses its bad taste to signal its powerful efficacy.
For products with many features, like the Oura Ring, focusing marketing on a single, primary problem (e.g., sleep) dramatically increases sales. Customers buy for the one clear solution and discover other benefits later, avoiding the cognitive overload of a long feature list.
Donald Miller argues that purchases are driven by words that are easy to understand, not by brand aesthetics. Making a customer think is a barrier to a sale. Simplifying your message to reduce mental effort is more effective than having a beautiful website or logo, as exemplified by Amazon's success.
For sophisticated consumers, branding based on unsubstantiated luxury materials can create skepticism. A marketing message focused on scientific proof, tangible benefits, and performance can be more compelling and build greater trust, especially for a high-price-point product.
A simple litmus test for unique brand positioning is to ask, "Could our competitor say this and have it be believable?" If the answer is yes, the message is too generic and not tied to a core, defensible differentiator. The message must be uniquely ownable.
Your promotional content must be immediately understandable to a distracted audience. If a 'drunk grandma' couldn't grasp your offer, it's too complex. Simplicity sells better than a superior product with confusing marketing because 'when you confuse, you lose.'
Move beyond listing features and benefits. The most powerful brands connect with customers by selling the emotional result of using the product. For example, Swishables sells 'confidence' for a meeting after coffee, not just 'liquid mouthwash.' This emotional connection is the ultimate brand moat.