A simple litmus test for unique brand positioning is to ask, "Could our competitor say this and have it be believable?" If the answer is yes, the message is too generic and not tied to a core, defensible differentiator. The message must be uniquely ownable.
Companies develop generic, ineffective messaging when trying to appeal to everyone, including hypothetical future personas. Real differentiation is a strategic choice to narrow your focus and clearly define who your product is *not* for.
While product differentiation is beneficial, it's not always possible. A brand's most critical job is to be distinctive and instantly recognizable. This mental availability, achieved through consistent creative, logo, and tone, is more crucial for cutting through market noise than having a marginally different feature set.
Defaulting to an uninspired name and logo (e.g., a family name with a roof icon) puts a business at an immediate disadvantage. In a saturated market, a unique brand is not a luxury but a foundational tool that provides marketing lift and prevents you from getting lost in the noise.
Generic claims like "family-owned" or "trustworthy" are no longer effective differentiators. A true Unique Selling Proposition (USP) must be specific to your operations—such as "same-day install" or "no weekend overtime charges"—making it impossible for competitors to easily copy your positioning.
When competitors falsely claim your unique features, don't abandon the message. Instead, teach prospects specific questions (e.g., "How many logins are there?") to expose the lie. Customers are delighted to call out vendors on their false claims, which solidifies your position and accelerates the sales cycle.
If your narrative is about a broad market problem (e.g., "data is growing") that isn't uniquely solved by your product, you're creating demand for the entire category, including your competitors. A powerful story must be built around your specific differentiator, making it a narrative only you can convincingly tell.
Positioning involves high-level strategic decisions about your market and competitors. Messaging is the critical next step: crafting the core sentences that bring that abstract strategy to life and direct all subsequent copywriting.
A powerful way to create a flagship message is to define a "villain." This isn't a competitor, but the root cause of the buyer's problem. For Loom, the villain is "time-sucking meetings." For Cloud Zero, it's "unpredictable cloud billing." This frames your product as the clear solution to a tangible enemy.
David Aaker identifies a simple, powerful tactic: ask your team what makes the company special—its "secret sauce"—and turn that into a formal brand asset. He argues even abstract concepts, like a unique way of treating people, can be branded (e.g., "the HP way") to create a potent, ownable differentiator.
Don't just list all your features. To build a strong 'why us' case, focus on the specific features your competitors lack that directly solve a critical, stated pain point for the client. This intersection is the core of your unique value proposition and the reason they'll choose you.