While AI agents promising perfect information sound beneficial, they may over-optimize for measurable specs. This devalues unquantifiable aspects like design, feel, and brand—the "soul" of a product. The result could be a marketplace of highly utilitarian but ultimately less human and desirable goods.
Related Insights
As buyers increasingly use AI as a research partner, the uniquely human aspects of a brand—trust, relationship, and service—become the most critical competitive advantage. When AI can compare features and pricing, the human experience is what will ultimately sway the decision.
Users are dissatisfied with purely AI-generated creative outputs like interior design, calling it "slop." This creates an opportunity for platforms that blend AI's efficiency with a human's taste and curation, for which consumers are willing to pay a premium.
AI agents shop based on optimized specs, not human heuristics like brand trust. This shift to "agentic commerce" could neutralize the power of major brands like Walmart and Amazon, and eliminate the interpersonal relationships that sustain local, small businesses.
As AI commoditizes the 'how' of building products, the most critical human skills become the 'what' and 'why.' Product sense (knowing ingredients for a great product) and product taste (discerning what’s missing) will become far more valuable than process management.
As models mature, their core differentiator will become their underlying personality and values, shaped by their creators' objective functions. One model might optimize for user productivity by being concise, while another optimizes for engagement by being verbose.
Future marketing must adapt to a world where the "customer" is an AI agent. These agents will bypass traditional persuasive tactics and brand narratives, instead performing objective, data-driven comparisons to find the best product. This forces brands to compete purely on measurable value and utility, fundamentally changing marketing strategies.
Even if AI can perfectly replicate all goods and services, human desire for authenticity, connection, and imperfection will create a premium for human-provided labor. This suggests new economies will emerge based not on efficiency, but on providing what is uniquely and quirkily human.
A key fear of machine-to-machine commerce is that it will optimize solely for the lowest price. However, the 'human in the loop' model ensures the agent acts as a curator, presenting options for a final human decision. This preserves the importance of brand, aesthetics, and subjective value beyond pure cost.
As AI commoditizes basic functionality, 'good enough' is no longer sufficient and will be considered mediocre. Sustainable advantage will come from the top of the stack: superior design, craft, brand, point of view, and storytelling.
As AI makes it incredibly easy to build products, the market will be flooded with options. The critical, differentiating skill will no longer be technical execution but human judgment: deciding *what* should exist, which features matter, and the right distribution strategy. Synthesizing these elements is where future value lies.
