The solution to product management's current issues isn't another framework. It's a "mental flywheel": start with a mindset of pragmatism and curiosity, which fuels creative action. This cycle is sustained by resilience and emotional detachment to handle inevitable setbacks and criticism.
Related Insights
Product management is inherently chaotic due to constant context switching, ambiguity, and difficult stakeholder conversations. Success isn't about finding a perfect process, but developing the resilience to navigate this mess and guide teams from ambiguity to clarity.
The product management role exists on a spectrum between building and bureaucracy. The profession has now skewed heavily toward the bureaucratic end, focusing more on process, frameworks, and coordination than on the creative act of building valuable products, losing its original "magic."
The current PM career path is flawed, driven by framework obsession, advice from inexperienced creators, and a premature rush to leadership. This creates "strategy theatre" where leaders lack foundational experience, perpetuating a cycle of ineffectiveness and contributing to the craft's demise.
Product Management evolved from a business function to a delivery role, then a strategic one with the rise of unicorns. However, it later devolved into a rigid "cult of best practice," where adherence to specific frameworks (like no-date roadmaps) became more important than the actual work itself.
Top product builders are driven by a constant dissatisfaction with the status quo. This mindset, described by Google's VP of Product Robbie Stein, isn't negative but is a relentless force that pushes them to question everything and continuously make products better for users.
A product team's effectiveness is not just about skills (competencies). It's equally dependent on the right behaviors (mindsets) and the supportive environment, culture, and leadership backing (resources). A full assessment must cover all three areas.
Bending Spoons' product lead argues that the ideal PM background is either entrepreneurial, which teaches focus on impactful work, or deeply analytical, which fosters an understanding of root causes. These two paths provide the core skills needed for product leadership.
Contrary to the popular belief that it's always detrimental, for product managers, context switching is a core strength. Fluidly moving between customer, engineering, and marketing conversations is essential for integrating diverse perspectives to bring a product to life.
Great PMs excel by understanding and influencing human behavior. This "people sense" applies to both discerning customer needs to build the right product and to aligning internal teams to bring that vision to life. Every aspect, from product-market fit to go-to-market strategy, ultimately hinges on understanding people.
In the rapidly evolving AI landscape where ideas are quickly commoditized, the most valuable trait for a product manager is not having one great idea, but possessing the creative skill to generate many good ideas consistently. This creative muscle is more important than being attached to a single concept.
