By stipulating a 6-month minimum contract with a 3-month cancellation clause, NBR created high friction for advertisers to leave. When clients called to cancel due to budget cuts, the 3-month notice period often made them reconsider and cut costs elsewhere instead, dramatically reducing churn.
Related Insights
When a buyer insists on a "termination for convenience" clause, explain that it nullifies the "length of commitment" lever. This effectively changes a multi-year agreement into a month-to-month one, which logically carries a much higher price (e.g., a 30-35% increase). This frames the clause not as a legal term, but a commercial one with a clear cost.
Reacting to churn is a losing battle. The secret is to identify the characteristics of your best customers—those who stay and are happy to pay. Then, channel all marketing and sales resources into acquiring more customers that fit this 'stayer' profile, effectively designing churn out of your funnel.
When a customer cancels, don't just offer a discount. Create a capture system that presents tailored solutions based on their stated reason—offer a plan downgrade for cost issues, a 15-minute setup call for confusion, or a feature workaround if something is missing. This preserves value while solving the root problem.
To increase retention, offer subscribers a permanent, high-value upgrade (e.g., 'free bacon for life') that they lose forever if they cancel their service. This leverages loss aversion, making the cost of churning much higher than the monthly fee.
The marketing landscape evolves too quickly for long-term commitments. Locking into even a 12-month contract can trap you with an underperforming agency while wasting money. Insist on month-to-month agreements to retain flexibility and ensure the partnership remains effective and accountable.
For high-ticket services with delayed results like SEO, use a 'Waived Fee' offer. Present a large one-time setup fee plus a monthly retainer. Then, offer to waive the setup fee if the client commits to a longer term (e.g., 12 months), with an early-out clause if performance metrics aren't met in 90 days.
Instead of focusing on long-term commitments, ask a potential agency what happens if you want to end the contract early. A truly confident partner, who believes in the results they can deliver, won't try to trap you with hidden fees or restrictive clauses.
Customers who pay a significant initiation fee are psychologically primed to stay longer to justify their initial investment, even if their monthly rate is lower. This "sunk cost fallacy" makes them a "stickier" customer than those on low-cost, no-commitment plans.
The public announcement to eliminate all ad revenue was a strategic marketing move. It sent a clear message to the market: if NBR relied 100% on subscriptions, the content must be exceptionally valuable and worth the high price point, reinforcing its premium positioning and justifying the cost.
Instead of maximizing ad slots, NBR removed all online ad inventory except the top banner. It then pitched a premium, simplified package to top clients for a high monthly fee, creating artificial scarcity and focusing on high-value partnerships. This secured over $1M in pre-sold, recurring revenue.