Business owners feel frustrated because their goal (driving traffic off-app to their website) is in direct conflict with social media's primary goal (maximizing on-app scroll time). This fundamental misalignment means the platform's success metrics work against your business objectives, creating a constant struggle for results.
Instead of focusing solely on conversion rates, measure 'engagement quality'—metrics that signal user confidence, like dwell time, scroll depth, and journey progression. The philosophy is that if you successfully help users understand the content and feel confident, conversions will naturally follow as a positive side effect.
Businesses claiming 'social media doesn't work' are blaming the tool, not the user. A tool's value is determined by the operator's skill. For an expert like LeBron James, a basketball is a billion-dollar asset; for an amateur, it's a liability. The same is true for marketing platforms.
Platforms optimize for their own goals, not yours. Don't mistake their vanity metrics (views, likes) for key business drivers. A clip with 100 million views can have an imperceptible impact on core goals like long-form downloads or newsletter sign-ups. Constantly ask "why" a metric matters to avoid platform capture.
Social media algorithms are "separators," showing content to a fraction of your audience to maximize on-platform time. Pinterest's algorithm is a "connector," aligning its goal (giving users the best answer) with your goal (reaching ideal clients), effectively matching you with people actively searching for your solutions.
Stop thinking of content as a one-way broadcast. A sophisticated approach involves creating posts designed to provoke responses. Then, systematically mine the comments for raw, unfiltered consumer insights, effectively turning your social channels into a free, real-time market research platform.
During a maternity leave, the speaker stopped posting on social media and discovered her sales and list growth remained consistent. The instant feedback of likes and comments was a "dopamine hit," but Pinterest was the quiet engine actually driving 80% of the results, revealing a major misalignment of time and effort.
Instead of treating social media as a long-term home, use it as a strategic tool to get your audience onto platforms you own, like an email list. The primary goal is to capture attention and immediately guide followers into your ecosystem, building a more resilient business off-platform.
Don't blame 'shadow banning' for declining reach. It's a function of supply and demand. As platforms mature, content supply explodes and ad spend increases, all competing for finite user attention. Your reach isn't being punished; it's being outbid in an increasingly crowded attention marketplace.
Pinterest deliberately interrupts the app experience for teens during school hours, prompting them to return later and even helping them turn off notifications. This counterintuitive move sacrifices short-term engagement to build a healthier user relationship, reinforcing its "time well spent" brand promise and fostering long-term loyalty.
Counterintuitively, dedicating budget to campaigns optimized for engagements, follows, and shares can be a powerful brand-building tool. This approach reaches more people less expensively than conversion campaigns, building an audience and 'searing memories' that lead to future demand, complementing direct response efforts.