During a maternity leave, the speaker stopped posting on social media and discovered her sales and list growth remained consistent. The instant feedback of likes and comments was a "dopamine hit," but Pinterest was the quiet engine actually driving 80% of the results, revealing a major misalignment of time and effort.
Guest Mae Pack built a multiple seven-figure handmade business after abandoning social media, which yielded low ROI and drained her energy. She instead focused on media outreach and collaborations, which aligned with her strengths and produced more impactful, long-lasting results.
A growing movement pushes back against the "always-on" demands of social media. This "slow marketing" prioritizes building sustainable systems that work for you, not against you. Pinterest is a key tool for this, rewarding consistent, strategic effort over constant performance and allowing for a life outside of work.
Platforms optimize for their own goals, not yours. Don't mistake their vanity metrics (views, likes) for key business drivers. A clip with 100 million views can have an imperceptible impact on core goals like long-form downloads or newsletter sign-ups. Constantly ask "why" a metric matters to avoid platform capture.
Unlike social media posts that disappear within 48 hours, the average Pinterest pin reaches 50% of its lifetime engagement over 13 months. This means content "ages like wine," with old pins continuing to drive traffic for years, creating a powerful, long-term marketing asset from a single effort.
The true cost of social media isn't just the time spent posting; it's the constant mental energy dedicated to it—planning content, checking engagement, and comparing yourself to others. Stepping away frees up significant cognitive "white space," allowing for deeper, more strategic thinking.
Email marketing delivers a powerful, unmatched return on investment, with industry figures suggesting up to a 40x return. A single strategic email can easily generate more revenue and direct results than weeks of consistent, effort-intensive social media posting, making it a highly leveraged channel.
The biggest misconception sold to entrepreneurs is that social media is mandatory for success. In reality, a solid business model, an email list, and effective ways for the right people to find you (like SEO) are the only true necessities. Social media can be "icing," but it shouldn't be the core "cake."
Shift the mindset from a brand vs. performance dichotomy. All marketing should be measured for performance. For brand initiatives, use metrics like branded search volume per dollar spent to quantify impact and tie "fluffy" activities to tangible growth outcomes.
Instead of treating social media as a long-term home, use it as a strategic tool to get your audience onto platforms you own, like an email list. The primary goal is to capture attention and immediately guide followers into your ecosystem, building a more resilient business off-platform.
Traditional marketing often involves an 80/20 split of creation to promotion. Pinterest's structure lets you flip this. Create one core piece of content (the 20%) and then generate numerous unique pins pointing to it (the 80%), maximizing the reach and lifespan of each content asset with minimal new creation.