Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

During recent geopolitical turmoil, commodity-exporting currencies have switched their primary driver (beta) from terms of trade to equity market performance. This behavioral shift mirrors the playbook from the 2022 Russia-Ukraine energy crisis, indicating a change in how these currencies react to macro shocks.

Related Insights

The surge in metals isn't just inflation (debasement). It's driven by emerging markets diversifying away from US dollar assets (de-dollarization) after Russia's assets were frozen, and a broader hoarding of physical assets that can't be seized amid rising geopolitical tensions.

Despite a major geopolitical shock, Emerging Market currencies have held up remarkably well. In contrast, EM rates markets have shown significant stress, indicating painful positioning squeezes and a reassessment of inflation risks by investors. This divergence signals underlying strength in some areas but reveals hidden fragilities in others.

A significant disconnect exists between soaring precious and industrial metal prices and the currencies of the exporting EM countries. Despite nations like Chile, Peru, and South Africa seeing a major terms-of-trade boost, their FX markets have not priced in this fundamental improvement. This suggests a potential investment opportunity, as fundamentals are expected to eventually impact asset prices more directly.

Beyond the typical 'flight to safety' in the US dollar during a crisis, a more nuanced currency play exists. Currencies of commodity-exporting countries, such as the Brazilian Real and Australian Dollar, are positioned to benefit from the positive terms-of-trade impact of higher energy prices.

A key relative value theme in FX is the widening gap between surging metal prices (gold, copper) and weaker oil prices. This creates a bearish outlook for oil exporters like Canada (CAD) and a bullish case for metal exporters like South Africa (ZAR) and Chile (CLP), amplifying a terms-of-trade driven strategy.

Markets often over-focus on relative interest rate policy when analyzing currencies. During an energy crisis, the macroeconomic effect of rising oil prices is a far more powerful driver. The disproportionate negative impact on energy-importing economies like Japan and Europe will weigh on their currencies more than any central bank actions.

Due to its low volatility and dollar-proxy properties, the Canadian Dollar (CAD) can outperform other high-beta currencies during risk-off events like an energy shock, even if the USD/CAD exchange rate itself is flat or rising.

The strategic value of commodities in a modern portfolio has shifted from generating returns to providing a crucial hedge against two growing threats. These are unsustainable fiscal policies that weaken currencies ('debasement risk') and the increasing use of commodities as geopolitical weapons that cause supply disruptions.

Despite strong price performance in commodities like copper and precious metals, the currencies of key EM exporting countries have not reacted as strongly as they should. This disconnect suggests that the 'terms of trade' theme is underpriced in the FX market, indicating potential valuation upside for these currencies.

The official NBER designation of a recession is less critical for commodity performance than the surrounding macro environment. For instance, the 1998 currency crisis crushed returns without a formal recession, while Chinese stimulus in 2008 caused a commodity melt-up during the GFC.

Commodity Currencies Shift Focus from Trade to Equities During Geopolitical Crises | RiffOn