The official NBER designation of a recession is less critical for commodity performance than the surrounding macro environment. For instance, the 1998 currency crisis crushed returns without a formal recession, while Chinese stimulus in 2008 caused a commodity melt-up during the GFC.
The ratio of leading-to-coincident economic indicators is at historic lows seen only in deep recessions (1982, 2009). However, this may be skewed by the leading indicators' reliance on extremely negative consumer sentiment surveys. This divergence suggests we might be at the bottom of a cycle, not the beginning of a downturn.
For commodities to benefit from reflation, rising inflation alone is not sufficient. It must be accompanied by a genuine economic and industrial rebound, indicated by rising Purchasing Managers' Indexes (PMIs). This combination dramatically improves commodity returns, especially for energy and industrial metals.
A powerful market signal is the "quad count," or the forecasted sequence of economic regimes. A progression from Quad 4 (recession fears) to Quad 3 and then to Quads 2 and 1 creates a powerful contrarian setup. This allows investors to buy assets like small caps when recession probabilities are priced at their highest.
“Crisis Alpha” is not a guaranteed hedge but the result of a managed futures strategy successfully capturing extreme macroeconomic shifts. The strategy is fundamentally about following major macro themes, with a crisis simply being one of the most intense themes it can follow.
Many commodity funds make bold macro predictions (e.g., on inflation) but take timid, diversified equity positions. A superior strategy is the reverse: maintain a neutral macro view while making concentrated, 'bold' bets on specific companies with powerful operational catalysts that generate alpha regardless of the macro environment.
During episodes of US government dysfunction, such as shutdowns, the dollar tends to weaken against alternative reserve assets. The concurrent strength in gold and Bitcoin provides tangible market validation for the 'dollar debasement' thesis, suggesting investors are actively seeking havens from perceived fiscal mismanagement.
For 50 years, commodity prices moved together, driven by synchronized global demand. J.P. Morgan identifies a breakdown of this trend since 2024, dubbing it the 'crocodile cycle,' where supply-side factors cause metals to outperform while energy underperforms, creating a widening gap like a crocodile's mouth.
According to Keith McCullough, historical backtesting reveals the rate of change of the U.S. dollar index is the most critical macro factor for predicting performance across asset classes. Getting the dollar right provides a significant edge in forecasting moves in commodities, equities, and other global markets.
Despite strong price performance in commodities like copper and precious metals, the currencies of key EM exporting countries have not reacted as strongly as they should. This disconnect suggests that the 'terms of trade' theme is underpriced in the FX market, indicating potential valuation upside for these currencies.
The reason for the Fed's rate cuts is critical. A "good" cycle with firm growth and declining inflation leads to strong commodity returns. Conversely, a "bad" cycle with decelerating growth and sticky inflation results in negative returns, making the 'why' more important than the 'what'.