The owner of Royal Air shifted her mindset from seeking measurable ROI for their mascot and community events. Instead, success is tracked through "quiet notices": overhearing positive comments, seeing branded buttons on kids' backpacks, and being recognized at events. This highlights the cumulative, qualitative impact of brand-building.
Ty Haney, founder of Outdoor Voices, reveals a key community-building step: relinquish brand control. By empowering super fans to host local events, the brand turns them into 'co-owners' of the experience. This generates more authentic engagement and word-of-mouth than centrally-managed marketing ever could.
For content without direct attribution, prove its value by systematically collecting qualitative feedback. Create a 'Trophy Room'—a document with screenshots of positive social media comments, Gong call mentions, and Slack messages—to tell a compelling story of impact beyond hard metrics.
DoubleTree's CFO reportedly hates the free cookie program because its ROI is impossible to prove. However, it functions as a powerful "talk trigger," generating priceless word-of-mouth marketing and brand loyalty. This proves the most effective brand initiatives often defy direct performance metrics.
Not all brand campaigns have direct, measurable ROI. Justify their cost by tracking "soft ROI," such as increased employee pride and retention (e.g., employees on billboards), positive candidate feedback during interviews, and using tools like Gong to track how often the campaign is mentioned in sales calls.
At MANSCAPED, organic social is not measured by direct sales attribution. Instead, its success is defined by its ability to generate earned media, build brand recognition, and foster community. This mindset allows the team to focus on creating culturally resonant content rather than just promotional posts.
Instead of chasing quantifiable but often misleading metrics like MQLs or pipeline attribution, focus on qualitative feedback from sales. Successful brand marketing means the sales team enters 'warm rooms' where customers are already familiar with and receptive to the company, eliminating the need to start from zero.
Instead of focusing on immediate ROI, structure events to foster genuine connections and goodwill ("karma"). This builds a stronger, more resilient brand over time, even if it means creating opportunities for competitors by inviting them.
Leading marketers confidently invest in high-cost, low-measurability channels like billboards and physical books. They understand that reaching a concentrated target audience builds brand in a way that can't be captured by direct attribution but drives long-term pipeline.
Instead of chasing perfect attribution, recognize that customers will explicitly tell you how they found you. At Drift, prospects on sales calls would frequently mention being fans of their podcast. This qualitative data from the front lines is often the most direct and powerful measure of brand impact.
The founders measure their podcast's success not by download counts but by the number of customers who visit the physical store and mention it. For a brand built on in-person experience, this qualitative, direct feedback is a more meaningful indicator of true engagement and impact than abstract digital analytics.