Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Routine inquiries from a majority owner are often misconstrued by managers as strategic mandates. Controlling shareholders must discipline themselves regarding what information they request to prevent accidentally distorting operational decision-making or elevating the wrong internal personnel.

Related Insights

PE firms often overwhelm portfolio management with requests without explaining the 'why'. By clearly linking each request to equity value creation from the outset, PE firms can better align and motivate the management team, which is their most critical asset for a successful exit.

To effectively influence a company's capital allocation, build a long-term relationship and privately educate management on your thought process. Avoid public activism or short-term demands like immediate share buybacks, which management teams often see through and dismiss.

A board member's role is to provide outside perspective to help a CEO think through a problem, not to make the decision. CEOs who ask 'what should we do?' risk abdicating responsibility to someone who lacks the deep operational context to make the right call. This can be destructive to a CEO's development.

According to Snap's Chairman Michael Lynton, a board chair's biggest mistakes are not operational but governmental. Their key role is to manage the board itself—by ensuring the right questions are asked of management and, crucially, by preventing individual board members from meddling in company operations.

"What's top of mind?" has become a generic trope that elicits canned answers. To get to the real drivers, ask spicier, more specific questions that uncover underlying pressures. Try asking, "Tell me what the board is pushing you on," because every executive has a boss and is dealing with external pressures.

Horowitz cautions against board members having daily, high-frequency interactions. A CEO ultimately must stand alone and develop high conviction to make difficult decisions. Constantly looking to an outsider for answers can stunt this growth and lead to poor outcomes, as the outsider lacks full context.

The distinction between a "director's question" and a "shareholder's question" is a false dichotomy. A board member's fundamental and only purpose is to act as a fiduciary for shareholders, meaning every question should be framed from their perspective.

Karri Saarinen argues that investors without direct operational experience often make better board members. They understand their role is to provide capital and high-level guidance, not dictate day-to-day strategy. This prevents them from misapplying lessons from their past company to your unique situation.

Many operators assume PE partners are always right and implement offhand suggestions as strategy. The best relationships involve a healthy give-and-take, where management uses data to validate or challenge the PE firm's ideas, preventing misguided decisions.

VC Seth Levine argues investors' primary power lies in influence, not control. Beyond investing or replacing a CEO, their role is to advise, not operate. He actively clarifies in board meetings that topics are for discussion to inform the CEO's decision, not for the board to decide, preventing investors from overstepping their role.