Rather than passively holding a stock, the "buy and optimize" strategy involves actively managing its weighting in a portfolio. As a stock becomes more expensive relative to its intrinsic value, the position is trimmed, and when it gets cheaper, it is increased, creating an additional layer of return.
Related Insights
The key to emulating professional investors isn't copying their trades but understanding their underlying strategies. Ackman uses concentration, Buffett waits for fear-driven discounts, and Wood bets on long-term innovation. Individual investors should focus on developing their own repeatable framework rather than simply following the moves of others.
Counter to conventional value investing wisdom, a low Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio is often a "value trap" that exists for a valid, negative reason. A high P/E, conversely, is a more reliable indicator that a stock may be overvalued and worth selling. This suggests avoiding cheap stocks is more important than simply finding them.
True understanding of a business often comes only after owning it. Taking a small (e.g., 1%) starter position can initiate the research process and shift your perspective from a casual observer to a critical owner, revealing nuances and risks not apparent from the outside.
Intrinsic value shouldn't be confused with a 12-month price target. It is a calculation of a company's long-term worth, akin to a private market or takeover value. This stable anchor allows investors to assess the "margin of safety" at any given market price and ignore daily noise, rather than chasing a specific trading level.
Allocate more capital to businesses with a highly predictable future (a narrow "cone of uncertainty"), like Costco. Less predictable, high-upside bets should be smaller positions, as their future has a wider range of possible outcomes. Conviction and certainty should drive allocation size.
To avoid emotional, performance-chasing mistakes, write down your selling criteria in advance and intentionally exclude recent performance from the list. This forces a focus on more rational reasons, such as a broken investment thesis, manager changes, excessive fees, or shifting personal goals, thereby preventing reactionary decisions based on market noise.
Anchoring valuation on a company's typical price-to-sales ratio helps identify buying opportunities when margins are temporarily depressed. This avoids the pitfalls of methods like the Magic Formula, which can mistakenly favor companies at their cyclical earnings peaks, leading to underperformance.
The sign of a working diversification strategy is having something in your portfolio that you're unhappy with. Chasing winners by selling the laggard is a common mistake that leads to buying high and selling low. The discomfort of holding an underperformer is proof the strategy is functioning as intended, not that it's failing.
To combat emotional decision-making, Eddie Elfenbein’s strategy mandates replacing exactly five of 25 stocks each year. This rigid structure forces patience and prevents impulsive trades, even when he feels tempted to sell a poorly performing stock. This system prioritizes long-term strategy over short-term reactions.
McCullough advocates for a "promiscuous" investment strategy, quickly moving capital to where signals are strongest. He argues that emotional attachment to winning positions, or "bag holding," is the primary way investors lose ground. The goal is to compound returns by avoiding drawdowns, not by marrying a single investment thesis.
