Employees often face surprise tax bills from equity compensation like RSUs because they don't perceive the value transfer as tangibly as a cash bonus. This psychological disconnect means they fail to proactively plan for the significant income tax event that occurs upon vesting, leading to unexpected financial strain.
Related Insights
To understand the real value of an incentive stock option (ISO) package, use an AI tool. By inputting the company's last funding round valuation, the total number of outstanding shares, and your specific grant details (number of options and strike price), you can get a clear notional value for your equity compensation.
The most powerful incentive for increasing employee ownership is to make founder exits to their employees tax-free. This aligns financial self-interest with a social good, making it more profitable for a founder to sell to their team than to private equity.
After their main exit, two founders received a secondary payout structured as a promissory note. This 'bonus' was taxed as earned income at a ~50% rate, not as capital gains (~25-30%). This structuring detail cut their net proceeds in half, highlighting a critical and non-obvious tax trap in complex M&A deals.
Granting stock options is only half the battle. To make equity a powerful motivator, leaders must constantly communicate a clear and believable narrative for a future liquidity event, such as an acquisition. This vision is what transforms paper ownership into a tangible and valuable incentive in the minds of employees.
Vested's CEO, Dave Thornton, a finance veteran, realized the massive market need for startup equity guidance only after his own mistaken advice led his employee to a huge tax bill during an acquisition. This personal failure highlighted that even financially savvy individuals struggle with the complexity of stock options.
While bonuses tied to revenue incentivize employees to perform specific tasks, they are purely transactional. Granting stock options makes team members think holistically about the entire business's long-term health, from strategic opportunities to small cost savings, creating true psychological ownership.
Gifting non-performance-based shares to all employees doesn't foster an 'owner mindset.' True ownership thinking is better cultivated through incentives tied to specific, controllable outcomes, like targeted cash bonuses. Standard equity compensation often just becomes another part of the salary package, disconnected from individual impact.
Stock options and equity are the primary drivers of wealth for employees, not salary. Unlike salary, which is taxed annually, equity value grows unimpaired by taxes until it's sold. This tax-deferred status allows for faster, unimpeded compounding over time.
When negotiating a job offer, ask for more stock options instead of a higher salary. This is often better received by employers as it signals you are a long-term believer in the company's success and want to be an "owner," not just an employee.
Founders often assume employees share their risk appetite for equity, but this is a mistake. When offered a choice between a higher cash salary and a mix of cash and equity, the vast majority of employees will choose the guaranteed cash, revealing a fundamental aversion to risk.