Benson Hill went public based on the booming plant-based protein movement. When the trend reversed and interest rates rose, its model shattered. This serves as a cautionary tale for AgTech companies building on fleeting consumer fads instead of fundamental market needs.
Focusing only on trendy sectors leads to intense competition where the vast majority of startups fail. True opportunity lies in contrarian ideas that others overlook or dismiss, as these markets have fewer competitors.
Brands like Sweetgreen and Allbirds, once buoyed by VC funds, are struggling. They had to raise prices to achieve profitability just as their core millennial customers faced inflation and job insecurity, leading to a collapse in demand and stock value.
Stocks like Chipotle and Cava, once valued at 35-100x forward P/E, are experiencing a major correction. The combination of declining traffic from their core younger demographic and a broader market shift away from frothy valuations is bringing these "growth" stocks back to earth.
Hershey's launch of a Dubai Chocolate product a full year after the flavor went viral on social media highlights a critical agility gap. The slow product development cycles of large corporations cannot keep pace with fast-moving digital trends, causing them to miss the peak of consumer interest and appear out of touch.
The narrative of "0 to $100M in a year" often reflects a startup's dependence on a larger, fast-growing customer (like an AI foundation model company) rather than intrinsic product superiority. This growth is a market anomaly, similar to COVID testing labs, and can vanish as quickly as it appeared when competition normalizes prices and demand shifts.
When creating a new food category, you invest heavily in educating consumers. Tariq Farid warns that if you don't control sourcing and maintain healthy margins, a competitor can easily replicate your product, import it cheaply, and capitalize on the demand you built.
Market dynamics are not static. What was once a 'wave'—a new, urgent problem for everyone—can evolve into a series of 'dams' and eventually a stable 'river.' A common mistake is to build for the hype of a wave after it has crested, by which point it no longer provides the same opportunity for explosive growth.
Existing agricultural giants have no incentive to process small batches of novel crops for startups. To prove market demand and achieve scale, innovators must acquire their own processing capacity, a risky but essential move to get products to market.
The past few years in biotech mirrored the tech dot-com bust, driven by fading post-COVID exuberance, interest rate hikes, and slower-than-hoped commercialization of new modalities like gene editing. This was caused by a confluence of factors, creating a tough environment for companies that raised capital during the peak.
Sprinkles' failure under private equity ownership wasn't just due to a fading fad. The PE model, which requires sustainable and predictable businesses (like car washes), is fundamentally incompatible with fad-driven, occasion-based products like gourmet cupcakes.