Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Miles Dieffenbach says QQQ compounded about 6X over ten years, roughly a 19-20% IRR. Applying a 2-and-20 fee load would leave the same return as the S&P 500, stripping out the alpha. He calls modern mega venture large-scale growth equity. Its risk-adjusted fee structure is hard to defend.

Related Insights

When venture firms drastically scale funds from tens of millions to billions, the underlying product transforms entirely. Dilution waterfalls on multi-billion-dollar exits yield low multiples for giant funds, driving managers to rely on guaranteed management fees over pure carry.

Because virtually every AI company pays a massive direct economic tax to Nvidia, hyperscalers, or foundational model providers, value naturally aggregates to public mega-cap tech stocks. Because limited partners can access those public giants through low-cost, zero-carry index funds, venture capitalists cannot rely on modest cash-on-cash multiples. Private tech funds must outperform public market equivalents by at least 1,000 basis points of IRR to justify their management fees.

To democratize venture capital, ARK created a fund that eliminates the traditional 20% carried interest (a share of profits). Instead, it charges a flat 2.75% management fee. This structure aims to give retail investors with as little as $500 direct access to premier private company cap tables without the performance fees that typically benefit fund managers disproportionately.

As venture capital firms scale to manage billions, their business model shifts from the 'artisan craft' of early-stage investing to an industrial process of asset gathering. This makes it difficult to focus on small, early opportunities and will likely result in IRRs that are no better than the industry average.

Miles Dieffenbach says Carnegie Mellon wants roughly a 4X net return, or 6-7X gross, from venture funds. For a $6B-plus multi-stage fund, even Anthropic's $18B round returning 20X may only return about 1X net; it cannot multiple the fund enough. He questions whether LPs can pencil clean risk-adjusted returns.

Despite median venture capital funds lagging public indexes like the S&P 500 for a quarter-century, capital continues to pour into the asset class. One LP describes this as 'hope over experience,' as investors are lured by the outlier returns of top funds, even though the average dollar invested underperforms.

Most VC funds fail to generate meaningful returns for LPs. Only the top quartile consistently delivers performance that justifies the risk. The asset class as a whole underperforms, challenging the idea that broader retail access would be beneficial.

The weighted average growth rate for Fundrise's VCX portfolio was 193%, crushing the 25% growth of the public QQQ index. This starkly quantifies how value accretion has shifted, with hyper-growth now happening almost exclusively in private markets before companies IPO.

Despite the allure of high returns, the median private equity fund does not beat public market benchmarks like the S&P 500 after accounting for high fees and illiquidity. Only the top decile or quartile of funds deliver the outperformance that justifies the associated risks and costs, making manager selection paramount.

The legendary investor calls venture capital's business model a "scam" because VCs get paid management fees regardless of performance. He argues this structure incentivizes deploying capital even on overly risky bets, as the manager's personal downside is limited while their upside is significant.