Jonah Weiner intentionally used dense, stylized prose in his newsletter's early days. This 'unhinged enthusiasm' repelled some readers but created a strong sense of community and initiation for those who stayed, effectively building a loyal core audience.
Related Insights
The podcast's business-themed Halloween costume contest, featuring ideas like a "terrifying tariff," successfully engages its specific audience. This fosters a strong sense of community and brand identity by creating inside jokes and shared experiences that resonate with their target listener persona.
The newsletter's founders intentionally resist expansion, avoiding the investor-driven pressure for scale that often compromises creative products. By focusing on a model that makes them happy and serves their existing audience, they've built a sustainable, highly profitable business without chasing growth for its own sake.
Instead of traditional marketing, using obscure channels forces your most dedicated fans to dig for information. This transforms them into evangelists who spread the word to the wider, more passive audience, creating an organic and powerful marketing engine built on scarcity and discovery.
The Savannah Bananas create deep fan loyalty by "world building," not just branding. They've developed an internal mythology with its own rules and language (e.g., the significance of the number 11). This makes fans feel like they're part of an exclusive, immersive universe, similar to Disney or Marvel.
Trained in traditional journalism where the writer remains in the background, Weiner had to pivot to a front-and-center persona for his newsletter. He found that putting himself forward was essential for asking people to pay for his work, tapping into his 'natural hamminess' to build a direct connection with his audience.
In specialized fields like fintech, subtle differences in terminology (e.g., "payment" vs. "payments") are powerful in-group signifiers. Getting these details right is critical for brands and ghostwriters to establish credibility. Getting them wrong immediately marks you as an outsider.
In a media landscape dominated by video, Blackbird Spyplane's deeply reported, text-only articles became some of their most widely shared work. This demonstrates that high-quality, in-depth written content can still find a large, engaged audience without needing a video or infographic component.
David Remnick acknowledges and embraces his magazine's identity as the "orthodox church of liberalism." This clear, unapologetic positioning creates a strong sense of community and loyalty. For a subscription business, serving a devoted "congregation" is more profitable than chasing a broad, dispassionate audience.
Gen Alpha's slang, like '6-7' or 'Skibbity,' is intentionally nonsensical. Unlike older slang with stable definitions, it functions as a rapidly changing cultural password, proving in-group status through shared, context-less memes rather than conveying specific meaning.
