While Q3 cocoa grinding data shows historically weak demand, it surpassed analyst expectations. This is highly significant because the underlying cocoa beans were purchased when prices were 25% higher, at extreme peaks. This suggests that demand destruction has a limit and is more resilient than previously thought, providing a potential floor for consumption even in high-price environments.
Related Insights
The discount between world cocoa prices and what farmers in Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana receive has narrowed dramatically, from as high as 75% to around 25-30%. This vast improvement in farm gate prices provides a powerful financial incentive for farmers to increase output, boosting investor confidence and signaling a long-term structural shift towards a more balanced and stable supply.
The cocoa futures curve is shifting into a 'contango' structure, where future prices are higher than spot prices. This technical change is a key indicator that the market expects bean availability to improve rapidly, allowing confectionery companies and other industry players to hedge and plan with greater confidence after a period of extreme volatility and scarcity.
For luxury brands, raising prices is a strategic tool to enhance brand perception. Unlike mass-market goods where high prices deter buyers, in luxury, price hikes increase desirability and signal exclusivity. This reinforces the brand's elite status and makes it more coveted.
Contrary to common belief, the home goods sector is facing a more challenging period now than during the 2008 recession. The massive pull-forward of demand during the pandemic created an artificially high peak, resulting in a deeper and more prolonged subsequent trough that is harder for businesses to navigate.
Pricing power allows a brand to raise prices without losing customers, effectively fighting the economic principle that demand falls as price rises. This is achieved by creating a brand perception so strong that consumers believe there is no viable substitute.
The global cocoa market is becoming less concentrated as production becomes more geographically diversified. Specifically, a significant increase in output and market share from Ecuador is helping to mitigate the industry's historical over-reliance on crops from Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana. This structural shift reduces systemic supply-side risk for the entire industry.
J.P. Morgan's bullish gold forecast isn't just about investor flight to safety. It's underpinned by inelastic mine supply failing to meet structurally higher demand from central banks, who can buy fewer tons at higher prices to maintain reserve targets, creating a strong floor for the market.
Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG) companies drove revenue through price increases, but this came at the cost of falling volumes. By pushing prices closer to the perceived value, they eliminated the "consumer surplus"—the extra value a customer feels they get. This made private label alternatives more attractive and damaged long-term brand relevance.
When a new KFC premium product wasn't selling, they doubled the price instead of discounting it. This aligned the price with consumer expectations for a premium item, signaling quality and causing sales to soar. Low prices can imply low quality for high-end goods.
For 50 years, commodity prices moved together, driven by synchronized global demand. J.P. Morgan identifies a breakdown of this trend since 2024, dubbing it the 'crocodile cycle,' where supply-side factors cause metals to outperform while energy underperforms, creating a widening gap like a crocodile's mouth.