Shopify's Harley Finkelstein argues agentic commerce will make SEO obsolete. Instead of brands gaming search rankings, AI will recommend products based on merit and a user's personal context history. This shift could level the playing field, allowing smaller, high-quality brands to be discovered more easily.

Related Insights

Anticipating a shift to "agentic commerce," SharkNinja is actively re-optimizing its e-commerce site for Large Language Models. The company believes what drives human conversion today may not rank highest in AI-driven search and expects commerce via AI platforms to be meaningful by Christmas 2025.

Following SEO, App Store Optimization, and social virality, the next major distribution channel is AI answer engines. Product teams must now strategize how to get their brand, features, and knowledge base indexed and surfaced in AI responses, making AEO a critical growth lever for the modern era.

With the rise of AI-driven agent search, consumers use conversational prompts ('What should I pack for Greece?') instead of simple keywords. To appear in these results, brands must shift from keyword optimization to tracking data on sources, sentiment, and contextual relevance to avoid becoming invisible.

Forward-thinking companies like Shark Ninja are not waiting for AI-driven "agentic commerce" to mature. They are actively optimizing their direct-to-consumer websites for Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT, anticipating that what drives conversion today may not rank well in future AI-powered searches.

Generative AI changes brand discovery from a budget-driven game to one based on relevance, credibility, and usefulness. This levels the playing field, allowing smaller, more agile brands to compete with larger incumbents who traditionally relied on massive ad budgets.

In AI-driven commerce, brands win by being selected by an agent, not by ranking on a search page. This shift favors brands with trustworthy, structured, and verifiable data over those with the largest advertising budgets, leveling the playing field for smaller, agile companies.

With 80-90% of AI-powered searches resulting in no clicks, traditional SEO is dying. The new key metric is "share of voice"—how often your brand is cited in AI-generated answers. This requires a fundamental strategy shift to Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), focusing on becoming an authoritative source for LLMs rather than just driving website traffic.

You.com CEO Richard Socher predicts a new marketing motion where companies market directly to LLMs. As AI agents increasingly make purchasing decisions and consume information, optimizing content for AI consumption will become as critical as traditional SEO.

The rise of AI agents means website traffic will increasingly be non-human. B2B marketers must rethink their playbooks to optimize for how AI models interpret and surface their content, a practice emerging as "AI Engine Optimization" (AEO), as agents become the primary researchers.

The primary channel for discovery is shifting from search engines (SEO) to AI-powered "answer engines" like ChatGPT. Product Managers are now responsible for this new distribution channel, requiring a strategy to ensure their brands and products surface in AI-generated responses.

Shopify President Predicts Agentic AI Will Replace SEO with Merit-Based Commerce | RiffOn