Nikesh Arora credits his hiring as an outside, non-expert CEO to having risk-taking VCs on the nomination committee. He argues that typical public boards optimize for safety, leading to "market return" hires. VCs introduce a higher risk appetite, enabling transformative leadership appointments.
Related Insights
Contrary to conventional wisdom, KP's most successful portfolio companies (like Rippling and Glean) overwhelmingly hire for potential, not past titles. 38 of the top 40 executive roles are filled by individuals reporting to the CEO for the first time, emphasizing adaptability and growth over a long resume.
A16z's decision to add Hollywood agent Michael Ovitz to their board was controversial but genius. It directly led to modeling the firm after Creative Artists Agency (CAA), a novel approach in venture capital. This shows the power of seeking board-level expertise from outside your industry to challenge core assumptions and unlock game-changing strategies.
Public company boards often hire CEOs using fuzzy adjectives like 'leader.' A better method is to first define 3-5 key strategic goals, creating a 'scorecard of success,' and then find a candidate whose track record specifically matches those objectives.
A16z's foundational belief is that founders, not hired "professional CEOs," should lead their companies long-term. The firm is structured as a network of specialists to provide founders with the knowledge and connections they lack, enabling them to grow into the CEO role and succeed.
PE sponsors can accelerate value creation by telling new CEOs that some new executive hires are expected to fail. This pre-approval removes the CEO's fear of appearing to have failed themselves, encouraging them to make necessary talent changes faster and more decisively.
Experience taught Herb Wagner that great leaders consistently surprise on the upside. He now weights leadership quality far more heavily, assessing CEOs not by interviews or charisma, but by their verifiable track record and through trusted backchannel references who have worked with them directly.
Even with full board support, a successor CEO may lack the intrinsic 'moral authority' to make drastic 'burn the boats' decisions. This courage is harder to summon without the deep-seated capital a founder naturally possesses, making company-altering transformation more challenging for an outsider.
Venture capitalists' common advice to 'up-level the team' with outside executives often overlooks a better option. Parker Conrad argues that promoting homegrown leaders is 'really underrated.' They possess deep institutional knowledge and established trust, which significantly lowers the risk compared to external hires.
Boards often default to replacing outgoing members with identical profiles, like a former CEO. An effective search professional must have the "intestinal fortitude" to challenge this, analyze the board's future strategic gaps, and propose candidates who fill those specific needs, which naturally surfaces more diverse talent.
Unlike operating companies that seek consistency, VC firms hunt for outliers. This requires a 'stewardship' model that empowers outlier talent with autonomy. A traditional, top-down CEO model that enforces uniformity would stifle the very contrarian thinking necessary for venture success. The job is to enable, not manage.
