Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

John Lear calls credit card delinquencies a head-scratcher because they are coming down even as gas prices rise and other consumer signals weaken. Mark Zandi says Equifax data show delinquency rates are elevated versus pre-pandemic but stable through September. Both see a resilient consumer.

Related Insights

Richmond Fed's Tom Barkin observes consumers strategically delaying non-essential payments (like summer gas bills or car insurance) and living with parents to free up cash for discretionary spending, demonstrating a resilient and creative mindset.

Top-line metrics like the debt service ratio suggest consumer finances are stable. However, microdata reveals a "K-shaped" divergence where many households are struggling. This paradox highlights the increasing inadequacy of using macroeconomic averages to assess the true health of the American consumer.

Instead of fueling a spending surge, this year's larger tax refunds helped consumers absorb the shock of high inflation, particularly in gas prices. This temporary cushion has propped up spending, but the underlying consumer is stretched, as seen in rising delinquencies.

Recent stress in credit card and auto loan markets is concentrated in loans originated in 2021-2023 when stimulus and looser standards prevailed. Lenders have since tightened, and newer loan portfolios are performing better, suggesting the problem is not spreading systemically.

John Lear says the 2022 vintages of auto and unsecured consumer loans were “gnarly” as stimulus wore off. Most lenders tightened underwriting in 2022 and 2023, so today’s vintages are improving. He still sees stress at the lower end of auto lending.

While lower-income households were hit first by inflation, a subsequent rise in delinquencies among middle and high-income groups signaled a deeper economic issue. It showed that sustained cost pressures were depleting even larger savings buffers, indicating the strain was not temporary or confined to one segment.

Despite numerous headwinds like high inflation and rising interest rates, consumers have continued to spend. This suggests a potential structural shift where consumers, fueled by wealth gains, are more willing to power through challenges by drawing down savings rather than cutting back.

The NY Fed reports a 13.1% credit card delinquency rate, while lender data (like Equifax's) shows 2.9%. The difference is the NY Fed includes charged-off debt from up to 7 years ago, which is rarely recovered. This "consumer view" creates a misleadingly dire picture of current financial health.

While the overall debt service ratio appears low, this average is skewed by high-income households with minimal debt. Lower and middle-income families are facing significant financial pressure and rising delinquencies, a critical detail missed when only looking at macroeconomic aggregates.

Although the proportion of consumers with subprime credit scores has decreased since 2019 (from 26% to 19%), overall delinquency rates have held steady. This indicates that financial stress is becoming more concentrated, with a smaller group of individuals experiencing delinquencies across multiple loan types simultaneously.