Don't dismiss megatrends like demographics and technology as only long-term concerns. Research from Vanguard's Joe Davis shows these forces account for roughly 60% of quarter-to-quarter changes in per capita GDP growth and earnings yield, making them immediate drivers of the business cycle.
Related Insights
Recent job growth is overwhelmingly concentrated in healthcare services (83% of new NFP jobs) for an aging population. This, combined with an AI capex bubble, reveals a non-dynamic, 'K-shaped' economy where 'Main Street' stagnates and growth depends on narrow, unsustainable drivers.
The AI boom's economic impact extends beyond direct investment. With AI plays driving 80% of stock market gains, a powerful 'wealth effect' is created. This disproportionately benefits the top 10% of earners, who in turn drive the majority of US consumer spending, fueling the broader economy.
While fears of job loss from automation dominate headlines, Vanguard's Joe Davis argues the real drag on economic growth is a *lack* of automation. The service sector, representing 80% of jobs, has seen little productivity improvement since the internet boom, leading to overall economic stagnation.
Michael Mauboussin argues the market is inherently long-term oriented. For major Dow Jones stocks, nearly 90% of their equity value is derived from expected cash flows beyond the next five years, debunking the common narrative of market short-sightedness and a focus on quarterly results.
The top 10% of earners, who drive 50% of consumer spending, can slash discretionary purchases overnight based on stock market fluctuations. This makes the economy more volatile than one supported by the stable, non-discretionary spending of the middle class, creating systemic fragility.
Joe Davis argues the economy faces a "tug of war" between an AI-driven boom and a deficit-fueled slump. He believes the mainstream forecast of stable 2% growth and 2% inflation is the least likely outcome, with an over 80% chance of a material change in the economic environment.
Consumer innovation arrives in predictable waves after major technological shifts. The browser created Amazon and eBay; mobile created Uber and Instagram. The current AI platform shift is creating the same conditions for a new, massive wave of consumer technology companies.
The top 10% of US earners now drive nearly half of all consumer spending. This concentration suggests the macro-economy and stock market can remain strong even if AI causes significant unemployment for the other 90%, challenging the assumption that widespread job loss would automatically trigger an economic collapse.
AI's contribution to US economic growth is immense, accounting for ~60% via direct spending and indirect wealth effects. However, unlike past tech booms that inspired optimism, public sentiment is largely fearful, with most citizens wanting regulation due to job security concerns, creating a unique tension.
Instead of predicting short-term outcomes, focus on macro trends that seem inevitable over a decade (e.g., more e-commerce, more 3D interaction). This framework, used by Tim Ferriss to invest in Shopify and by Roblox for mobile, helps identify high-potential areas and build with conviction.
