Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

Former NBC News President Deborah Turness reflects that the brand recovered from the Brian Williams scandal faster than she expected. She believes that in today's fragmented and polarized media environment, a similar crisis would inflict much greater, longer-lasting damage.

Related Insights

Instead of viewing impartiality as passive neutrality or "both-sidesism," former BBC News CEO Deborah Turness sought to "weaponize impartiality." This frames journalistic balance as an active, forceful tool that provides a distinct value proposition in a media landscape pulled to ideological extremes.

Facing a ratings spiral after a co-anchor's firing, new president Deborah Turness used audience research to uncover viewers' core desires: substance, emotional connection, and uplift. This data-driven insight became the foundation for the successful brand turnaround.

Even though anyone can create media, legacy brands like The New York Times retain immense power. Their established brands are perceived by the public as more authoritative and trustworthy, giving them a 'monopoly on truth' that new creators lack.

Deborah Turness, former head of NBC and BBC News, contrasts the '90s, when broadcast felt creative and print was stodgy, with today. She argues that legacy print brands have significantly advanced and innovated, while the broadcast industry has largely stood still.

A controversy over biased editing, amplified by Donald Trump, damages the BBC's key advantage in the US market: its perceived neutrality. Being publicly attacked by a US president erodes its "above the fray" positioning, recasting it as just another player in America's domestic political battles.

Brands that have survived for 50-100 years are likely to survive another 50 (the 'Lindy Effect'). Their audiences feel a sense of ownership, making them incredibly loyal and forgiving. This creates a durable, defensible asset that is hard to kill, even with mistakes.

Former BBC CEO Deborah Turness warns that large media brands must learn from the creator economy. She urges them to stop "managing" the news and instead empower talent to build authentic, direct relationships with audiences, mirroring platforms like Substack and YouTube.

Trust can be destroyed in a single day, but rebuilding it is a multi-year process with no shortcuts. The primary driver of recovery is not a PR campaign but a consistent, long-term track record of shipping product and addressing user complaints. There are very few "spikes upward" in regaining brand trust.

Deborah Turness, having led news organizations in both countries, reflects on Brian Williams' career comeback after his scandal. She posits that the U.S. is a "land of second chances" for public figures in a way that the more unforgiving UK media market is not.

CBS News acquiring Bari Weiss signals a strategic shift: legacy media outlets are buying influential independent creators to regain credibility. As audiences increasingly trust individual voices over institutions, these giants are co-opting top creators to bring that trust—and their audiences—back under a corporate umbrella, reversing the traditional talent pipeline.

Legacy Media Brands Are Less Resilient to Scandal Than a Decade Ago | RiffOn