Gryphon Investors correctly identified the risk of unhedged debt but delayed execution for six months due to "perfectionism." This costly mistake underscores that in volatile markets, timely implementation of risk management strategies is more critical than achieving a perfect execution plan.
Related Insights
After profiting from its GFC hedges, Fairfax over-learned the lesson and continued hedging equities from 2010 to 2016. This protective stance became so costly in a bull market that it completely wiped out all operating income for that period, causing massive underperformance against the S&P 500.
Options are an excellent tool for risk management, not just speculation. When you have a high-conviction view that feels almost certain (e.g., "there is no way they'll hike"), buying options instead of taking a large vanilla position can protect the portfolio from a complete wipeout if your seemingly infallible view is wrong.
Post-mortems of bad investments reveal the cause is never a calculation error but always a psychological bias or emotional trap. Sequoia catalogs ~40 of these, including failing to separate the emotional 'thrill of the chase' from the clinical, objective assessment required for sound decision-making.
While seductive, complex trades with multiple conditions (knock-ins, knock-outs) create numerous ways for a core thesis to be correct on direction but still result in a loss. Simplicity in trade expression is a form of risk management that minimizes the pain of a good call being ruined by flawed execution.
Investors often underestimate how easily years of compounded gains can be erased by a single bad decision, such as using excess leverage or making an emotional choice. Downside protection is not merely a defensive strategy; it's a vital, offensive component for ensuring the compounding engine survives to continue running.
Howard Marks argues that you cannot maintain a risk-on posture and then opportunistically switch to a defensive one just before a downturn. Effective risk management requires that defense be an integral, permanent component of every investment decision, ensuring resilience during bad times.
A common investor mistake is underwriting a deal that requires 15-20 different initiatives to go perfectly. A superior approach concentrates on 3-5 key value drivers, recognizing that the probability of many independent events all succeeding is mathematically negligible, thus providing a more realistic path to a strong return.
A core discipline from risk arbitrage is to precisely understand and quantify the potential downside before investing. By knowing exactly 'why we're going to lose money' and what that loss looks like, investors can better set probabilities and make more disciplined, unemotional decisions.
Reframe hedging not as pure defense, but as an offensive tool. A proper hedge produces a cash windfall during a downturn, providing the capital and psychological confidence to buy assets at a discount when others are panic-selling.
Investors often believe their analysis is correct even if their timing is off, leading to losses. The reality is that in markets, timing is not a separate variable; it's integral to being right. A poorly timed but eventually correct bet still results in a total loss.
