True product excellence lies in details users might not consciously notice but that create a magical experience. Like Jobs' obsession with internal aesthetics, these small, polished edge cases signal a culture of craft and deep user empathy that is hard to replicate.
A powerful innovation technique is "humanization": benchmarking your product against the ideal human experience, not a competitor's feature set. This raises the bar for excellence and surfaces opportunities for deep delight, like Google Meet's hand-raise feature mimicking in-person meetings.
To cultivate strong design taste without formal training, immerse yourself in best-in-class products. Actively analyze their details, from menus to spacing, and ask *why* they work. This reverse-engineering process builds intuition and raises your personal quality bar faster than theoretical study alone.
Consumers perceive products as higher quality when they are aware of the effort (e.g., number of prototypes, design iterations) that went into creating them. This 'labor illusion' works because people use effort as a mental shortcut to judge quality. Dyson's '5,127 prototypes' is a classic example.
True differentiation comes from "deep delight," where emotional needs are addressed within the core functional solution. This is distinct from "surface delight" like animations or confetti, which are nice but fail to build the strong emotional connections that drive loyalty.
Product 'taste' is often narrowly defined as aesthetics. A better analogy is a restaurant: great food (visuals) is necessary but not sufficient. Taste encompasses the entire end-to-end user journey, from being greeted at the door to paying the check. Every interaction must feel crafted and delightful.
A failure to show basic courtesy, like tilting an umbrella for someone on a sidewalk, is analogous to inconsiderate product design. Most products are oblivious to their user's experience. Building with genuine empathy and consideration is a powerful, rare competitive advantage that fosters emotional connection and advocacy.
Most companies complete the first 80% of brand work (logo, colors, tagline). Truly great brands are defined by the last 20%: obsessively aligning every detail, from employee headphones to event swag, with the core identity. This final polish is what customers actually notice and remember.
While not a formal metric, the feeling of being "blown away" by a product—like a Tesla's self-driving or an iPhone's interface—is a powerful qualitative signal. This direct, pre-intellectual perception of excellence can tell you more about a company's "roots" and future potential than financial analysis alone.
Robinhood's superior user experience isn't just the design team's responsibility; it's a core part of the company's DNA, driven by leadership. The CEO and VPs spend significant time on design details, ensuring a high bar for polish that competitors often neglect.
The era of winning with merely functional software is over. As technology, especially AI, makes baseline functionality easier to build, the key differentiator becomes design excellence and superior craft. Mediocre, 'good enough' products will lose to those that are exceptionally well-designed.