While serving a past version of yourself works initially, clinging to this strategy stunts growth. As your expertise evolves, your messaging gets stuck on beginner problems. This attracts buyers requiring constant convincing, not those ready for the advanced transformation you now offer.
Many established marketers are ineffective because they rely on outdated strategies. A newcomer, free from this baggage, has a competitive advantage because they can bring fresh, unbiased perspectives to solve problems. This reframes imposter syndrome as a potential strength.
Traditional pain-point marketing ('Aren't you tired of...') attracts people stuck in their problems and reinforces a negative state. 'Mirror Messaging' attracts your 'Highest Self' buyer by reflecting the transformation they seek, calling in people who are actively looking for a solution.
Don't try to force customers to adopt new behaviors, like a boot-buyer purchasing sandals. Instead, focus on encouraging them to buy a second pair, a newer model, or an upgraded version of the product they already love. This audience-focused approach builds on existing loyalty and is far more effective.
As businesses scale, they often abandon the scrappy, creative tactics that sparked their initial growth. To combat rising ad costs and channel fatigue, intentionally revisit these early, 'unscalable' activities. Re-injecting that fun, different energy can generate the 'free memories' and reach needed for the next growth phase.
As you and your business mature, your messaging must evolve in lockstep. You will naturally outgrow your old messaging before your audience does. If you don't update it, you'll become trapped serving an old identity, unable to attract clients who match your current level of expertise.
Visionary founders often try to sell their entire, world-changing vision from day one, which confuses buyers. To gain traction, this grand vision must be broken down into a specific, digestible solution that solves an immediate, painful problem. Repeatable sales come from a narrow focus, not a broad promise.
The "build it and they will come" mindset is a trap. Founders should treat marketing and brand-building not as a later-stage activity to be "turned on," but as a core muscle to be developed in parallel with the product from day one.
A common PLG pitfall is assuming the user base will naturally springboard into enterprise deals. Often, the enterprise buyer is a different person with different problems. This oversight can cost companies years, as they have to build a second, separate sales motion from scratch.
Entrepreneurs often burn out speaking to 'Former Self' or 'Working Self' buyers who require constant convincing and tactical steps. The 'Highest Self' buyer, who purchases transformation and alignment, is the key to scaling. Your messaging should mirror their desired identity, not their pain.
For a mature company like Square, the primary marketing challenge is not building awareness but correcting an outdated public perception. Many customers still associate them with their original 'little white reader,' unaware of the full product portfolio, requiring a strategy focused on education and perception shift.