Instead of positioning against direct competitors in a saturated category, frame your message against what your customer is *actually* using today. A DAM tool resonated better when it shifted messaging from being a "better DAM" to helping users "move on from Dropbox and Drive."

Unlike sales-led companies that get feedback from sales calls, PLG companies are blind to their competitive positioning without formal research. You must conduct jobs-to-be-done interviews to uncover why customers chose you over alternatives, as relying on internal assumptions or simple "what do you love" surveys is misleading.

The competitor's name, 'Practice,' was a significant liability because it was impossible to search for, track mentions, or differentiate from other tools. This made organic marketing and competitive intelligence incredibly difficult, contributing to their lack of visibility despite being well-funded. A unique, searchable name is a marketing asset.

While many founders fear competitors, Michael Dubin views them as beneficial. He argues that rivals forced Dollar Shave Club to sharpen its brand identity and focus on its unique strengths. Competition validates the market opportunity and pushes the incumbent to work harder and be more specific about its value.

Generic claims like "family-owned" or "trustworthy" are no longer effective differentiators. A true Unique Selling Proposition (USP) must be specific to your operations—such as "same-day install" or "no weekend overtime charges"—making it impossible for competitors to easily copy your positioning.

If your narrative is about a broad market problem (e.g., "data is growing") that isn't uniquely solved by your product, you're creating demand for the entire category, including your competitors. A powerful story must be built around your specific differentiator, making it a narrative only you can convincingly tell.

Instead of general analysis, feed your AI a defined customer persona (e.g., "Growth Gabby") and ask it to evaluate a competitor's website copy from that specific perspective. This uncovers messaging weaknesses that directly relate to your target audience's concerns, like complexity or pricing.

A simple litmus test for unique brand positioning is to ask, "Could our competitor say this and have it be believable?" If the answer is yes, the message is too generic and not tied to a core, defensible differentiator. The message must be uniquely ownable.

While ignoring competitors is naive, constantly reacting to their every move is a crutch for founders who lack a strong, opinionated vision for their own product. Healthy balance involves strategic awareness without sacrificing your own roadmap.