Recent census data reveals a significant shift in U.S. internal migration. High housing costs are pushing residents out of traditionally fast-growing states like California, while more affordable states, including some in the Midwest, are experiencing population growth for the first time in a decade.
Related Insights
A key driver of recent rent inflation, especially for lower-cost housing, was the population increase from mass immigration. Citing a Wharton study, the speaker claims a 1% population increase in a city leads to a 1% rent increase, presenting a direct, quantitative link between immigration policy and housing affordability.
The difference in home price trends between US regions is not about weather or jobs, but housing supply. States in the South and West that permit widespread new construction are seeing prices fall, while "Not In My Backyard" (NIMBY) states in the Northeast and Midwest face shortages and rising prices.
Despite the current affordability crisis, underlying demographic trends from young millennials and Gen Z create a massive, long-term structural demand for housing. This will require approximately 18 million new units through 2030, irrespective of short-term market cycles.
The state's most visible problems—homelessness, high costs, and corporate exodus—are framed not as complex policy failures but as the direct result of a singular, decades-long failure to build enough housing, office space, factories, energy, and transportation infrastructure.
Contrary to most industries that see technological gains, housing construction has become less efficient. This stagnation is a key, often overlooked driver of housing affordability issues, as the fundamental cost to build has not decreased with technology.
The American housing market is increasingly inaccessible to younger generations. The median age of a homebuyer has hit a record high of 59, the same age one can access retirement funds. Even the median first-time buyer is now 40, indicating a systemic affordability crisis.
The number of 25-34 year olds living with parents has doubled from 10% to 20% since 2000. This represents a significant "housing deficit" of unformed households, which will drive strong demand for new housing as soon as affordability improves.
The pandemic-era migration to remote work hotspots is reversing. As inward migration slows and borrowing costs rise, cities like Austin and Denver now lead the US in the share of home sellers forced to reduce their asking prices, creating a new wave of economic pressure on top of declining commercial property values.
The core of the affordability crisis plaguing American families is a national shortage of 3-4 million housing units, particularly for middle-income workers and first-time buyers. This is not just a collection of local zoning issues but a macroeconomic problem that directly impacts consumer sentiment and economic well-being.
While local policies like zoning are often blamed for housing crises, the problem's prevalence across vastly different economies and regulatory environments suggests it's a global phenomenon. This points to systemic drivers beyond local supply constraints, such as global capital flows into real estate.