Curtis Sliwa argues that true masculinity isn't defined by symbols of power like guns but by a commitment to protecting the vulnerable—the poor, elderly, and infirm. He frames it as a moral responsibility to risk one's life for strangers, a form of humanitarian service that stands in stark contrast to conventional notions of strength.

Current fiscal policies represent a massive wealth transfer from young to old. Framing national service as a direct, large-scale investment in youth counteracts this economic imbalance, shifting national priorities and resources back to the next generation, effectively fighting a 'generational war' through policy.

Forcing children to do difficult, undesirable manual labor from a young age builds foundational character and discipline that pays dividends in later life. While they will hate it at the time, this 'character building' instills a level of resilience that modern children often lack.

When raising boys, a father's actions are far more impactful than his words. Instead of lecturing on what it means to be a man, consistently demonstrating service, respect, and responsibility will be internalized by a son over time, even if the lesson isn't explicit or is initially met with embarrassment.

National service offers a structured "gap year" for boys, whose emotional maturity often lags their development. It acts as a "societal take-two," providing a second chance to mature and find direction without immediate academic or career pressures, specifically addressing a cohort in crisis.

Ancient societies universally used rites of passage—difficult, often dangerous, solitary journeys—to transition youth into adulthood. These trials forced them to confront failure and discover their capability, fostering a confidence and competence that modern society struggles to instill without such structured challenges.

Unlike many cultures, modern America lacks a defining moment that marks a boy's transition into manhood. This cultural void can lead to confusion. Historically, institutions like the military or intentional acts by fathers served this purpose, but their decline has left a developmental gap.

A key reason for past legislative success was that leaders shared a common identity forged in military service. Reinstating mandatory national service could create 'connective tissue' among diverse young people, fostering a unified identity as citizens first and foremost, before individual identity groups.

Manhood isn't an age but a state of being generative: producing more jobs, love, and care than you consume. This reframes masculinity around contribution rather than status or age, offering a clear, actionable goal for young men to strive for.