CEOs provide a curated view of their company's culture. To get an accurate picture, talk to people who have left the organization on good terms for an unfiltered perspective. Also, ask behavioral questions like 'What would you tell a friend to do to be successful here?' to uncover the real cultural DNA.
WCM realized its intensely caring culture risked becoming too soft, potentially enabling underperformance. They consciously implemented a practice of 'truth-telling'—having direct, difficult conversations about performance—as a necessary counterbalance to maintain high standards and ensure accountability.
WCM assesses both its own culture and that of potential investments by looking for an 'absence of fear,' a concept from Whole Foods founder John Mackey. This intangible quality indicates a high level of trust and psychological safety, which they believe is a prerequisite for high performance and innovation.
The true ROI of a great company culture is operational velocity. Long-tenured employees create a high-context environment where communication is efficient, meetings are shorter, and decisions are faster. This 'shared language' is a competitive advantage that allows you to scale more effectively than companies with high turnover.
Instead of aiming for vague outcomes like "empowerment," start by defining the specific, observable behaviors you want to see. For example, what does "being data-driven" actually look like day-to-day? This focus allows you to diagnose and remove concrete barriers related to competency, accessibility, or social reinforcement.
Instead of starting from a textbook, WCM developed its effective culture by identifying the negative traits of its original founder's regime—control, opacity, and stinginess—and deliberately doing the opposite. This 'inversion' method provides a powerful, practical template for cultural transformation.
When a CEO consistently emails on nights and weekends, it's a clear signal of a high-intensity work culture with low work-life balance. For candidates, this isn't just about the CEO's schedule; it's a cultural red flag or green flag depending on their own work preferences and expectations.
Culture isn't about values listed on a wall; it's the sum of daily, observable behaviors. To build a strong culture, leaders must define and enforce specific actions that embody the desired virtues, especially under stress. Abstract ideals are useless without concrete, enforced behaviors.
A powerful way to gauge cultural fit is to identify who is succeeding within the organization. Then, honestly assess if you respect them and their methods. If the path to "thriving" is paved by behaviors you don't admire, it signals a fundamental misalignment and may not be a game you want to win.
Senior executives are, by definition, excellent at interviewing, making the process unreliable for signal. Instead of relying on a polished performance, ask to see the 360-degree performance reviews from their previous company. This provides a more honest, ground-truth assessment of their strengths and weaknesses.
Standard reference checks yield polite platitudes. To elicit honesty, frame the call around the high stakes for both your company and the candidate. Emphasize that a bad fit hurts the candidate's career and wastes everyone's time. This forces the reference to provide a more candid, risk-assessed answer.