Treat your startup like a drug discovery experiment. A market's needs are like biological 'binding receptors'—they either exist or they don't. Marketing can raise awareness of your 'drug' (product), but it can't convince the body to grow new receptors. If you lack product-market fit, don't try to market your way out of it.
Related Insights
Rabois introduces a nuanced framework beyond just product-market fit. He argues that exceptional marketing can create a temporary illusion of success, but this "marketing fit" will eventually collapse if the underlying product value isn't there to retain users.
Committing all resources to a single demand trigger is a post-product-market fit move. Early on, founders need a broader approach to discover the repeatable patterns of demand. Only after identifying this pattern from early customers can you confidently build a concentrated "tollbooth" around it.
Successful startups tap into organic customer needs that already exist—a 'pull' from the market. In contrast, 'conjuring demand' involves a founder trying to convince a market of a new worldview without prior evidence. This is a much harder and less reliable path to building a business.
Founders mistakenly treat their product idea as fixed while searching for customers. The correct mindset is the reverse: customer needs are a fixed reality. Your product is the variable you must shape to fit that reality, not the other way around.
When a startup finally uncovers true customer demand, their existing product, built on assumptions, is often the wrong shape. The most common pattern is for these startups to burn down their initial codebase and rebuild from scratch to perfectly fit the newly discovered demand.
Founders must distinguish between persistence and fighting a losing battle. If you constantly feel like you're pushing a boulder uphill to convince the market, you're on the wrong path. Genuine product-market fit feels like the market is pulling you, and your job is to sprint to keep up.
Technical founders often create a perfect solution to a real problem but still fail. That's because problem-solution fit is useless without product-market fit. An elegant solution that isn't plugged into the market—with the right GTM, pricing, and messaging—solves nothing in practice. It's unheard and unseen.
Many marketing failures aren't the marketer's fault, but a result of joining a company that lacks true product-market fit. Marketers excel at scaling demand for something with proven value, not creating demand for a vague idea. It's crucial to verify PMF before accepting a role.
This reframes the fundamental goal of a startup away from a supply-side focus (building) to a demand-side focus (discovery). The market's unmet need is the force that pulls a company and its product into existence, not the other way around.
Using a child's toy analogy, demand is a pre-existing hole (e.g., a star shape) and your product is the block. Founders fail when they build a block and then search for a hole it fits. The real job is to first deeply understand the shape of the hole, then craft a block that fits it perfectly.