CEO Ben Lamb counters ethical criticism by arguing that humanity is already negatively "playing God" by causing mass extinction. He posits a moral obligation to use technology to reverse the damage we've caused, turning the common critique on its head.
Related Insights
Tech billionaire Bill Gates supports a radical concept called solar radiation management: releasing aerosols to reflect sunlight and cool the planet. This moves the idea of a "sun visor for Earth" from science fiction to a seriously considered, albeit controversial, last-resort solution for climate tipping points.
Many top AI CEOs openly admit the extinction-level risks of their work, with some estimating a 25% chance. However, they feel powerless to stop the race. If a CEO paused for safety, investors would simply replace them with someone willing to push forward, creating a systemic trap where everyone sees the danger but no one can afford to hit the brakes.
Facing immense ethical questions about technologies like artificial wombs, Colossal doesn't wait for regulation. It establishes its own clear, public guardrails—such as refusing to work on humans or primates and tying every project back to conserving an existing endangered species.
Top AI leaders are motivated by a competitive, ego-driven desire to create a god-like intelligence, believing it grants them ultimate power and a form of transcendence. This 'winner-takes-all' mindset leads them to rationalize immense risks to humanity, framing it as an inevitable, thrilling endeavor.
Colossal CEO Ben Lamb argues that the scientific community's debate over whether his creation is a "true" dire wolf is a semantic distraction. He contends this argument overshadows the unprecedented scientific milestone of creating live animals from 12,000-year-old DNA.
The race to build AGI, framed with "religious zealotry," puts hyperscalers in a prisoner's dilemma where none can slow down. This narrative justifies abandoning prior 'net zero by 2030' commitments in favor of immediate, power-intensive buildouts using fossil fuels, under the belief that the eventual 'machine God' will solve the resulting climate problems.
AI will create negative consequences, like the internet spawned the dark web. However, its potential to solve major problems like disease and energy scarcity makes its development a net positive for society, justifying the risks that must be managed along the way.
Other scientific fields operate under a "precautionary principle," avoiding experiments with even a small chance of catastrophic outcomes (e.g., creating dangerous new lifeforms). The AI industry, however, proceeds with what Bengio calls "crazy risks," ignoring this fundamental safety doctrine.
Colossal CEO Ben Lamb, a software entrepreneur with no biology background, approached top geneticist George Church seeking world-changing problems. His ability to build teams and secure capital, unconstrained by scientific dogma, was key to launching the ambitious de-extinction venture.
To justify the unprecedented capital required for AI infrastructure, Sam Altman uses a powerful narrative. He frames the compute constraint not as a business limitation but as a forced choice between monumental societal goods like curing cancer and providing universal free education. This elevates the fundraising narrative from a corporate need to a moral imperative.
