We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Greg Roche agrees interview performance says little about job performance, joking you might as well flip a coin. He recommends gathering outside data: back-channel references, observing how candidates treat the front desk or lunch host, and using Glassdoor only as context for better questions. Roche calls interviews a weak predictor.
For hiring, Scott Galloway advocates for prioritizing "reference hiring" above all else. He trusts a strong recommendation from a credible source so much that he considers the candidate an "80, 90% lock on the job" before they even interview. This suggests vetted referrals are a far more reliable signal of quality than traditional interview performance.
Research shows work samples are the single highest predictor of a candidate's future success, yet most companies over-rely on conversational interviews. Integrating a hands-on project or work trial provides immense signal for the company and gives the candidate a realistic preview, which also enables powerful self-selection.
Use the maxim, "How someone does anything tells you how they do everything." Assess a candidate's preparation for the interview itself. Their research, note-taking, and follow-up are direct predictors of their future diligence and performance in the role.
At Meta, an interviewer's stated confidence in their hiring decision correlates more strongly with a candidate's future on-the-job performance than the raw interview feedback. This suggests that calibrated interviewers develop an intuitive 'gut check' that captures a candidate's potential for success beyond the formal rubric.
Standard reference calls are predictably positive. To get the truth, ask the reference, "What job do we need to hire next to help this person be successful?" The description of the required role will almost always be a perfect antonym of the candidate's skills, revealing their weaknesses.
Interviews are often misleading. A trusted recommendation from a high-performing employee or contact is a more reliable signal of a candidate's quality than your own interview assessment. This "reference hiring" is a secret weapon for building a strong team.
A common hiring mistake is prioritizing a conversational 'vibe check' over assessing actual skills. A much better approach is to give candidates a project that simulates the job's core responsibilities, providing a direct and clean signal of their capabilities.
According to Ferrari, unstructured interviews are among the worst predictors of job performance. Conversational chats lacking rigid rubrics yield subjective sentiment rather than useful evaluation. To generate predictive power, companies must mandate strictly uniform, highly specific questions for all candidates, record the answers, and decouple the evaluation of those responses entirely from the person conducting the interview.
The strong impression from a job interview creates a false sense of 'knowing' who will be a good hire. This vivid, face-to-face interaction leads managers to overweight its value and discount more predictive data. Adding an unstructured interview can therefore make hiring predictions worse than using objective data alone.
Senior executives are, by definition, excellent at interviewing, making the process unreliable for signal. Instead of relying on a polished performance, ask to see the 360-degree performance reviews from their previous company. This provides a more honest, ground-truth assessment of their strengths and weaknesses.