Greg Roche says compensation committees likely picture “charisma” when they read executive presence, stakeholder influence, and cross-functional collaboration. That association favors the loud person in front of the group, even though quieter people can build strong one-on-one connections and communicate effectively. Roche argues those terms are fuzzy and often reward style over quieter strengths.
Greg Roche was told repeatedly that he did not speak up enough and looked “aloof.” Instead of adding verbal filler, he began asking the questions already in his mind. That showed engagement, gave him processing time, and let him redirect discussion; he says leaders can invite quiet attendees to do the same.
Greg Roche agrees interview performance says little about job performance, joking you might as well flip a coin. He recommends gathering outside data: back-channel references, observing how candidates treat the front desk or lunch host, and using Glassdoor only as context for better questions. Roche calls interviews a weak predictor.
Greg Roche defines engagement as willingness to expend discretionary effort, not visible activity. Quiet employees may deliver results without talking in meetings, then get misread as checked out. He warns leaders to judge output and effort rather than equate extroverted behavior with being engaged, and notes introverts may be especially poor at self-promotion.
Greg Roche says introverts often assume results speak for themselves, but he warns nobody else will publicize their work. He coaches them to share accomplishments in authentic, one-on-one ways and tells leaders to create visibility for quiet contributors, because promotions depend on being known as well as delivering.
Greg Roche coaches introverts to email five leaders individually and ask for 15 minutes to answer one career question: what contributed most to their success? They talk, you listen, then they ask about your work. Repeat across leaders, and talent reviews include advocates who know your results, not just your name on a spreadsheet.
Greg Roche names payroll and finance as critical partners in total rewards. By first learning why those colleagues chose their jobs, he could later ask for grace on a late bonus file or discuss a budget gap without cold-emailing a stranger. Introverts should build such one-on-one ties before needing them.
Greg Roche left a corporate VP role partly because leadership meant meeting after meeting about work rather than the work itself. Fractional consulting reduced draining meetings and let him scope projects, but he still had to network for clients; his direct business came through relationships, not marketing. It suits introverts if they accept that trade-off.
Greg Roche says engagement surveys usually return anonymous aggregates, so items about speaking up or volunteering can confuse introversion with disengagement. A quiet engineering-heavy company may score low without revealing whether people are willing to expend discretionary effort. He warns against treating engaged as extroverted and disengaged as introverted.
Greg Roche argues performance reviews should ask whether someone lived the values and delivered results, not whether they fit fuzzy personality labels. Terms like executive presence let charisma bias creep in. Removing personality descriptors and rewarding outcomes makes reviews fairer for quiet contributors who get results through different styles.
Greg Roche says managers should directly ask quiet attendees what they are thinking during meetings. A simple “what questions do you have?” gives introverts a low-pressure entry point, reveals their processing, and keeps the loudest voice from dominating. He calls this a concrete way leaders can engage half their workforce.
Greg Roche warns that highly charismatic leaders often have a shadow side, with personality traits you may not want running the company. Promoting on presence alone can backfire. Reviews should separate outcomes from the traits that may produce them, so quieter leaders with strong results are not automatically discounted.
