Sales reps at market leaders often succeed due to brand strength and inbound leads, not individual skill. Instead, recruit talent who proved they could win at the #3 company in a tough market. They possess the grit and creativity needed for an early-stage startup without a playbook.
Related Insights
At the $1-10M ARR stage, avoid junior reps or VPs from large companies. The ideal first hire can "cosplay a founder"—they sell the vision, craft creative deals, and build trust without a playbook. Consider former founders or deep product experts, even with no formal sales experience.
A startup's initial salesperson should prioritize mirroring the founder's successful sales approach. Their job is to deconstruct the founder's "hook" through observation and trial-and-error, not to immediately implement formal sales processes, metrics, or a CRM. Success comes from successful knowledge transfer, not premature system building.
When evaluating sales leaders, prioritize their track record in recruiting above all else. Exceptional leaders are talent magnets who build scalable teams through strong hiring and enablement. Their ability to attract A-players is the foundation of a predictable revenue machine.
A powerful recruiting tactic is to ask a new customer, "Who would you have bought from if their product was better?" This question identifies competitor reps who excel at selling—persuading buyers despite product disadvantages. These individuals are prime candidates to recruit for your own team.
When direct access to top talent is blocked by competitors, savvy leaders identify other successful companies with strong sales cultures (a "lineage") and strategically recruit from that pool. This allows them to tap into a new vein of proven, high-potential talent.