Amy Porterfield found her newsletters with the highest open rates and clicks were those sharing personal stories, not just promoting content. This human connection, she argues, is the most powerful business strategy available to a creator.
Related Insights
Counterintuitively, highly formatted and image-heavy emails can feel corporate and impersonal, decreasing engagement. Shifting to a simpler, plain-text style mimics a personal message from a friend, which increases perceived authenticity and encourages more replies and genuine connection.
During a major launch, the creator continued sending her regular story-driven newsletter. By weaving in authentic stories related to the launch theme and a subtle CTA, these emails generated over $300,000, proving that connection-focused content can outperform hard sales pitches.
Frame email subject lines to appeal to the higher-level position your audience desires. A manager wants to know what a CMO is doing. This psychological tactic, which plays on ambition, can lift open rates by 24-28% over standard personalization by speaking to who your audience wants to become.
From Nov 20th to Dec 20th, sending a personal letter-style email from a founder or executive to unengaged contacts can increase open rates by 40%. The key is changing the "from name" to a person, not the brand, and using a subject line that acknowledges their absence. This strategy works for both B2B and B2C brands.
Focusing on email open rates can lead to clickbait subject lines and weak copy. Instead, orient your entire outreach strategy around getting a reply. This forces you to write more personalized, engaging content that addresses the recipient's specific pain points, leading to actual conversations, not just vanity metrics.
Leverage AI in email marketing not to replace your voice, but to augment it. Use tools like ChatGPT as a brainstorming partner to generate angles and outlines. This frees up your creative energy to focus on infusing the content with personal stories and genuine connection that only a human can provide.
Beyond marketing metrics, actively soliciting replies on non-business topics (e.g., "What's your favorite hobby?") uncovers valuable first-party data about your audience's interests. This enables more relatable and personalized content that resonates on a human level.
Email marketing delivers a powerful, unmatched return on investment, with industry figures suggesting up to a 40x return. A single strategic email can easily generate more revenue and direct results than weeks of consistent, effort-intensive social media posting, making it a highly leveraged channel.
Personal newsletters are resurging as a sanctuary from the exhaustion of social media. Creators crave a space for deeper context away from performative platforms, while audiences seek intentional, high-value content that respects their attention, leading to a boom in personality-driven newsletters.
To make your emails more engaging, stop addressing your entire list. Instead, picture one specific, real person—a friend, an ideal client, or someone you admire—and write directly to them. This simple mental shift transforms your tone from a generic broadcast into an intimate, compelling conversation.