A new media hierarchy has emerged where authenticity trumps production value. At an event, the audience reaction was muted for A-list celebrities but erupted for live streamers. This suggests raw, interactive formats build deeper connections and greater influence than polished, traditional media.

Related Insights

Gary Vaynerchuk argues that platforms have evolved beyond a follower-based model ("social media"). Now, algorithms dominate, creating an "interest media" landscape where content is surfaced based on a user's demonstrated interests, regardless of whom they follow. This makes the content itself paramount over follower counts.

The middle ground of social content is disappearing. To succeed, creators must either produce hyper-professional, cinematic-quality work or embrace completely raw, authentic, unedited content. Attempting to compete with gimmicky, mid-level edits is a losing strategy as it fails to stand out.

Contrary to fears that AI would devalue events, it has amplified their importance. As digital spaces become saturated with AI-generated content, conferences and meetups are becoming the primary venue for authentic human interaction, original ideas, and building genuine trust.

Mark Zuckerberg's evolution from a highly media-trained, scripted persona to an authentic public figure shows that the old playbook of message control is dead. The market now rewards leaders who are transparent and genuine ("this is me, deal with it"), even if they are less polished. Synthetically generated authenticity is easily spotted and rejected.

A Mr. Beast event revealed a clear content hierarchy. Live streamers received the most audience applause, followed by long-form creators, then short-form creators, with traditional celebrities last, demonstrating the power of raw, interactive content.

The founder of Stormy AI argues large influencers are in trouble because social algorithms no longer guarantee reach based on follower count. Viral potential is now decoupled from follower count, meaning a nano-influencer can achieve massive views. This makes them a more cost-effective and potent marketing channel for brands than established stars.

The "authenticity" that makes video performers successful is a constructed performance of understanding an unseen audience while staring into a camera. It's a specific, under-theorized skill of transmission, not a reflection of one's true self, making the term "authentic" a misnomer for a calculated craft.

Acquired's hosts intentionally stopped sharing research to create authentic on-air reactions. This improvisational element adds emotional depth and surprise, signaling to the audience what's important and making complex topics more engaging than a scripted delivery ever could.

As audiences push back against AI-generated and overly polished stock imagery, featuring real people in authentic situations will be critical for engagement. Showcasing your team, customers, or volunteers in natural settings—not on a green screen—builds trust and connection, making genuine humanity the key to cutting through the noise.

Andrew Ross Sorkin emphasizes that for the DealBook Summit, the audience is as important as the stage talent. By filling the room with peers and other influential leaders, speakers feel compelled to engage more deeply, knowing they are being judged by people whose opinions matter to them.