Despite the unusual dynamics in G7 volatility, the strategist warns that for crowded high-yield emerging market carry trades, the old rules still apply. If the consensus trade is upended for any reason, EM volatility and risk reversals are expected to 'blow up,' making protective options a prudent hedging strategy.

Related Insights

The positive outlook for EM assets is now a consensus view, dangerously reliant on two core assumptions: a strong global cyclical backdrop and the outperformance of metals over energy. This widespread agreement creates a "lack of imagination" for potential downsides, making the market vulnerable if these pillars falter.

The success of the current EM FX carry trade isn't driven by wide interest rate differentials, which are not historically high. Instead, the strategy is performing well because a resilient global growth environment is suppressing currency volatility, making it profitable to hold high-yielding currencies against low-yielders.

A popular investment strategy involves borrowing cheap Japanese Yen to buy higher-yielding US assets. This creates a hidden vulnerability. A sudden strengthening of the Yen would force these investors into a mass, simultaneous fire-sale of their US assets to cover their loans, triggering a systemic liquidity crisis.

A decoupling is occurring where EM high-yield currencies are outperforming DM high-beta currencies. Investors are increasingly using DM currencies as funders to capture attractive carry in select EMs like South Africa (precious metals), Mexico (stable carry), and Hungary (improving fundamentals).

Improving risk-adjusted carry in intra-EMU spreads is deceptive, driven by falling volatility, not higher returns. This creates a 'carry trap' where a small one-standard-deviation widening can erase one to two months of gains, highlighting the risk in currently crowded positions.

The market believes the Fed is more likely to ease on weak data than tighten on strong data. This perceived asymmetry in its reaction function effectively cuts off the 'negative tail risk' for global growth, making high-yielding emerging market carry trades a particularly favorable strategy in the current environment.

Contrary to the historical norm where volatility rises with a strengthening dollar (risk-off), the market is now experiencing higher volatility as the dollar falls. This unusual 'dollar down, vol up' dynamic suggests a pro-cyclical market backdrop and has major ramifications for how FX options and risk reversals are priced.

Long-term strategic investment plans for emerging markets, however well-researched, can be completely derailed by short-term, headline-driven, technical market volatility, forcing a re-evaluation of the core narrative.

While broad emerging market currency indices appear to have stalled, this view is misleading. A deeper look reveals that the "carry theme"—investing in high-yielding currencies funded by low-yielding ones—has fully recovered and continues to perform very strongly, highlighting significant underlying dispersion and opportunity.

Despite a supportive macro environment, the most immediate threat to emerging market assets comes from increasingly crowded investor positioning. As tactical indicators rise, assets become vulnerable to sharp corrections from sentiment shifts, a dynamic recently demonstrated by the Brazilian Real's 5% drop.