Improving risk-adjusted carry in intra-EMU spreads is deceptive, driven by falling volatility, not higher returns. This creates a 'carry trap' where a small one-standard-deviation widening can erase one to two months of gains, highlighting the risk in currently crowded positions.
Related Insights
While still profitable, FX carry trades have become more cyclical and less of a diversifier. They now exhibit a high correlation (~0.5 beta) with the S&P 500 and offer significantly lower yields (7% vs. 11-12% previously), increasing their risk profile in a potential market downturn.
With the European Central Bank firmly on hold, a low-volatility regime is expected to persist. However, the options market is not fully pricing in the potential for directional curve movements, such as steepening or flattening. This creates opportunities to express curve views through options where the risk is undervalued.
The success of the current EM FX carry trade isn't driven by wide interest rate differentials, which are not historically high. Instead, the strategy is performing well because a resilient global growth environment is suppressing currency volatility, making it profitable to hold high-yielding currencies against low-yielders.
A decoupling is occurring where EM high-yield currencies are outperforming DM high-beta currencies. Investors are increasingly using DM currencies as funders to capture attractive carry in select EMs like South Africa (precious metals), Mexico (stable carry), and Hungary (improving fundamentals).
Despite a packed calendar of central bank decisions and key data releases, broad FX volatility is hovering near five-year lows. This suggests investors are underpricing potential market moves, and current options pricing for events like U.S. payrolls may be insufficient to cover a significant data surprise.
The market believes the Fed is more likely to ease on weak data than tighten on strong data. This perceived asymmetry in its reaction function effectively cuts off the 'negative tail risk' for global growth, making high-yielding emerging market carry trades a particularly favorable strategy in the current environment.
While broad emerging market currency indices appear to have stalled, this view is misleading. A deeper look reveals that the "carry theme"—investing in high-yielding currencies funded by low-yielding ones—has fully recovered and continues to perform very strongly, highlighting significant underlying dispersion and opportunity.
The European Central Bank's stable, "on hold" position has created a low-volatility environment for European rates. This policy predictability supports specific trading strategies, such as tactical range trading, using call spreads instead of outright long duration, and shorting gamma to capitalize on the expectation of continued low delivered volatility.
Despite high Euro risk reversals against the dollar, J.P. Morgan identifies a broad underperformance in Euro skew, particularly in LATAM crosses like EUR/BRL and EUR/MXN. This dislocation creates an attractive setup for volatility harvesting strategies, such as selling topside Euro calls through delta-hedged structures.
With credit spreads already tight, their potential upside is limited while their downside is significant in a recession scare, offering poor convexity. Goldman Sachs advises that a better late-cycle strategy is to move up the risk curve via equities, which offer more upside potential, rather than through credit investments.
