We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.
Miles Dieffenbach says a key investor departure gets deep scrutiny in CMU's re-up decisions, especially if that person drove performance. He also flags funds whose shape, form, or strategy has drifted from what was underwritten five to seven years earlier, making the old return math unworkable.
Miles Dieffenbach says CMU will not back a manager for only a fund or two if the job is a 15-year commitment. He checks whether they love the work, speaks with founders and past coworkers, and looks for enough GP commitment that leaving would hurt.
With high partner turnover at large venture firms, a key diligence question for founders is whether the specific partner joining their board is likely to remain at that firm. A partner's departure can be highly disruptive, making their stability more important than firm brand.
The traditional PE model—GPs exit assets and LPs reinvest—is breaking down. GPs no longer trust that overallocated LPs will "round trip" capital into their next fund. This creates a powerful incentive to use continuation vehicles to retain assets, grow fee-related earnings, and avoid the fundraising market.
Limited Partners (LPs) value fund managers who are willing to listen and internalize market feedback, even if they ultimately follow their own strategy. This openness is a key positive signal, while a refusal to listen is a major red flag that often appears early in the relationship.
Capital Group values managers who maintain a consistent investment style (e.g., value or growth) and avoid "style creep," especially during skewed markets. Since the firm manages risk by combining managers with different styles, an individual changing their approach midstream creates an unintended, problematic portfolio imbalance.
Top-quartile performance no longer guarantees fundraising success. LPs recommit to mega-funds like KKR and Blackstone not for exceptional returns, but for institutional safety. This mitigates key-man risk for the LP and, crucially, career risk for the individual making the allocation decision.
Lara Banks of Mechanic Capital passed on a successful fund because she couldn't verbalize the repeatable 'intangibles' driving their returns. LPs must be able to understand and explain a VC's process for generating returns, not just see past luck, before committing capital to a fund.
To avoid emotional, performance-chasing decisions, institutional LPs should create a 'kill list' for each manager. This document pre-defines the fundamental criteria for redemption, ensuring that exit decisions are based on a disciplined, pre-agreed framework rather than market noise.
The long-held belief in performance persistence in private equity is weakening. Early academic studies were flawed because they analyzed finalized fund data, whereas re-up decisions are made mid-fund life. Newer data shows that picking managers based on their last fund's performance is "certainly not foolproof, if helpful at all."
Relying on an established VC's past performance creates a false sense of security. The critical diligence question for any manager, emerging or established, is whether they are positioned to win *now*. Factors like increased fund size, team changes, and evolving market dynamics mean a great track record from 5-10 years ago has limited predictive power today.