/
© 2026 RiffOn. All rights reserved.

Get your free personalized podcast brief

We scan new podcasts and send you the top 5 insights daily.

  1. Private Equity FunCast
  2. Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)
Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast · Sep 23, 2026

PitchBook data reveals private equity mega-funds face diminishing returns. Bigger isn't better as performance lags, relying on beta & leverage.

The Largest Private Equity Deals Often Result in EBITDA Margin Declines, Questioning the 'Operational Improvement' Narrative

Data from 2000-2021 shows a startling trend: in 9 of those 21 vintage years, the largest buyout deals experienced EBITDA margin declines post-acquisition. This contradicts the core private equity value proposition of improving operational efficiency and suggests returns are heavily reliant on financial engineering rather than making businesses fundamentally better.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

Asset Allocation Models Often Assume a Flawed 300 Basis Point Premium for Private Equity

A common practice in institutional portfolio modeling is to simply assume private equity will outperform public equity by a fixed premium, often 300 basis points. This simplistic assumption, rather than rigorous analysis, drives allocation decisions and creates self-fulfilling demand for the asset class, irrespective of actual, risk-adjusted performance.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

Large LPs Choose Marquee Private Equity Funds for 'Career Risk' Mitigation, Not Superior Returns

The decision to allocate to massive, well-known PE funds is often driven by behavioral factors like career risk. Similar to the old adage "you don't get fired for buying IBM," allocators choose brand-name managers for defensibility and convenience, even if performance data suggests smaller funds may offer better returns.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

Middle-Market Private Equity Funds Have Consistently Outperformed Mega-Funds Over the Past Decade

Despite massive capital flows to the largest funds, middle-market funds have demonstrated superior performance for over ten years post-GFC. The challenge for large LPs is not performance, but the structural difficulty of deploying large checks into smaller funds without becoming over-diversified and reverting to the mean.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

The 'Swenson Model' of Heavy Private Market Allocation May No Longer Work As Capital Floods the Industry

The success of the Yale/Swenson model was predicated on a first-mover advantage in an uncrowded market. Today, with trillions in AUM, the private equity landscape is intensely competitive. Increased competition among LPs for top managers and among GPs for deals has eroded the pricing power and advantages that pioneering endowments once enjoyed.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

PitchBook's Research Finds Private Equity 'Operational Alpha' Is Largely Sector Picking, Leverage, and Multiple Expansion

A neural network trained by PitchBook concluded that much of what PE firms call "operational alpha" can be replicated by systematically selecting companies in favorable sectors (like tech), applying more leverage than public market counterparts, and benefiting from market-wide multiple expansion, rather than superior operational improvements.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

As Private Equity Buyout Funds Grow Larger, Their Performance Relative to the Broader Market Has Consistently Declined

PitchBook's analysis of "marquee" or household-name buyout managers shows a clear downward trend in performance. On a capital-weighted basis, these large funds have seen their relative performance scores degrade over time, recently falling below the median and underperforming the rest of the fund universe.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

Historical Top-Quartile Performance is No Longer a Reliable Predictor of Future Private Equity Fund Success

The long-held belief in performance persistence in private equity is weakening. Early academic studies were flawed because they analyzed finalized fund data, whereas re-up decisions are made mid-fund life. Newer data shows that picking managers based on their last fund's performance is "certainly not foolproof, if helpful at all."

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

Private Equity's Smoothed Valuations Create 'Volatility Laundering,' Skewing Asset Allocation Models

PE returns appear artificially smooth because they are based on infrequent, private valuations. This "volatility laundering" mathematically lowers standard deviation and correlation inputs in asset allocation models. It makes the asset class seem less risky, causing models to systematically over-allocate capital to it based on flawed risk assumptions.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago

Large LPs' Need to Deploy Massive Checks Structurally Favors Underperforming Mega-Funds

A huge LP like CalPERS may need to deploy $15-20 billion annually. This operational constraint makes allocating to smaller, better-performing middle-market funds impractical. The need to write huge checks forces them into mega-funds that can absorb the capital, creating a demand-driven consolidation cycle independent of performance.

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook) thumbnail

Diminishing Returns to Scale in Private Equity (w/ Andrew Akers, PitchBook)

Private Equity FunCast·2 months ago